Duty Hours Reforms in the United States, France, and Canada: Is It Time to Refocus Our Attention on Education?

Abstract

Resident duty hours restrictions have now been instituted in many countries worldwide. Such policies have resulted in a broad-based discussion in the medical literature concerning their effects on patient care, resident education, and resident well-being. To better understand the impetuses behind these changes, the authors examine not only the duty hours mandates currently in effect in the United States, Canada, and France, but also the events influencing their independent development in these three countries. In the United States, an 80-hour resident workweek was mandated by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education out of concern for patient safety. In France, a 52.5-hour workweek was decreed by the government, reflecting the broader European Working Time Directive initiated out of concern for the negative impact of extended work hours on its population. In Canada, resident unions, whose primary interest has been one of resident well-being, have negotiated a series of reduced resident duty hours that approach those mandated in the United States. At the core of these changes are unique differences in these countries' health care and medical education systems. The resulting diversity in the origin and nature of such regulations serves to highlight the lack of evidence that has guided their development and the need to refocus on the educational elements of postgraduate training.

Understanding Resident Learning Preferences Within an Internal Medicine Noon Conference Lecture Series: A Qualitative Study

“…21 Internal medicine residents reported less exposure to formal conferences after the 2003 restrictions on duty hours. 22 Because of its efficiency at delivering content in the …”

Perceived sleepiness in Canadian anesthesia residents: a national survey

“…In Ontario, for example, the maximum on-call duration for an anesthesia resident is 25 h (24 plus 1 h for handover). 42 The average weekly work hours of Canadian anesthesia residents are fewer than the upper limits stated in the United States guidelines but more than the European Union directive. Currently, 96% of residents in our study reported work weeks that exceed the current EWTD limit, and 10% of residents reported work weeks that exceed the United States guidelines.…”

Characteristics of pediatric intensive care residency programs in Argentina. A national survey

“…20,21 In France, resident duty hours were restricted to 52.5 hours per week. 22 The National Ministry of Health of Argentina establishes that residents should work, at least, 48 hours per week and complete not more than eight on-duty shifts per month. 4 There is evidence that an excessive work load and an inequitable distribution of duties lead to burnout 19,23,24 and cause high rates of depersonalization and emotional exhaustion among residents.…”