The COVID-19 pandemic created an unprecedented shift in students' learning environments that caused students who planned on in-person instruction to learn online instead. This change affected students' learning attitudes, anxiety, and success. In this work, we present students' personal voices to better understand how sudden disruptions in education affected students over nearly two years of transitioning between online and in person classes. In particular, we surveyed students during the Winter 2022 term in which, at the University of California Irvine, classes started online and transitioned back to in person after four weeks. We collected and analyzed students' written responses to four open-ended survey prompts that asked students to describe how they adapted to online learning and to the transition back to in person learning. We performed inductive coding of the students' responses to discover emergent themes from these first hand accounts of student experiences, and we discuss students' challenges and successes related to themes such as motivation, time management, maintaining a work/life balance, communication with peers, and access to technology and a quiet place to study. In these responses, students clearly describe both benefits and drawbacks to both transitioning to online courses and transitioning back to in person. These results provide important implications for student wellness in multiple learning formats and through disruptive transitions in learning.