Driving for Real or on a Fixed-Base Simulator: Is It so Different? An Explorative Study

Abstract

International audienceThe use of driving simulators to assess driving abilities is often controversial because of their artificiality. Our aim is thus to tackle this question by estimating and comparing new indicators such as the mental workload, the psychological feeling (e.g., stress, anxi- ety, pleasure, and mastery), and feeling of presence when driving a simulator and a real vehicle (either one’s own or one that belongs to a driving school). We are most inter- ested in a particular sort of real-world driving: the driving school. This situation has two advantages: It matches our own particular interest in the evaluation of driving abilities and, to some extent, it is as artificial as driving in a simulator. Fourteen expert drivers participated in this study. Each driver was invited to complete two questionnaires (i.e., the NASA-TLX and Questionnaire of Psychological Feeling) that relate to the various driving conditions (i.e., simulator, driving school vehicle, and personal vehicle). The heart rate of drivers was also recorded at rest and during some of the driving condi- tions. Our results indicate that the feeling of presence was, for some of its component parts, identical in both the simulator and in a real car. Moreover, in both the simulator and real car, none of the assessments of presence revealed values that were close to 100%; indeed, sometimes they were considerably lower. This result leads us to believe that presence may often be underestimated in virtual environments because of the lack of an objective value of reference in the real world. Moreover, results obtained for mental workload and affective feeling indicate that a simulator can be a useful tool for the initial resumption of driving after a period off the road. In particular, a simulator can help to avoid the sort of stress that can lead to task failure or a deterioration in per- formance

Quantifying the Physiological Stress Response to Simulated Maritime Pilotage Tasks

“…A recent investigation of driving in real and simulated environments reported considerable similarity in the structure of individual task workload responses for simulated and real-world driving. 47 Encouragingly, findings from the same study indicated that there was no significant difference for stress response between driving in a simulated environment, and driving in one's own vehicle. 47 …”

On-Road Evaluation of Autonomous Driving Training

“…All these limitations are necessary and legitimate, but they confine user tests to experts in the field and keep final users distant from them. Driving simulators reduce this gap, but, although their effectiveness has been proven for traditional cars [29], very little is known about their validity when the level of automation increases.…”

Get ready for automated driving using Virtual Reality

“…When it comes to Driving Simulation (DS), VR is used to study several aspects of the driving task. In this context, moving-base simulators [10] are preferable to fixedbase simulators [11,12] for their closer approach to realworld driving [13]. By investigating the physical, behavioral and cognitive validity of these kind of simulators with respect to the real driving task [11], it has been also shown that DS can be a useful tool for the initial resumption of driving, because it helps to avoid stress that may lead to task failure or deterioration in performance.…”