Driving Fatigue Classification Based on Fusion Entropy Analysis Combining EOG and EEG

Abstract

The rising number of traffic accidents has become a major issue in our daily life, which has attracted the concern of society and governments. To deal with this issue, in our previous study, we have designed a real-time driving fatigue detection system using power spectrum density and sample entropy. By using the wireless technology and dry electrodes for EEG collection, we further integrated virtual reality simulated driving environment, which made our study more applicable to realistic settings. However, the high accuracy of classification for driving fatigue has not been obtained. To measure the time series complexity of the EEG signal, we proposed a fusion entropy (sample entropy, approximate entropy, and spectral entropy) analysis method of EEG and EOG. First, a sample entropy was applied for feature extraction from the horizontal and vertical EOG. Second, an approximate entropy, sample entropy, and spectral entropy features of each sub-band of EEG are extracted. Third, feature fusion for sub-band is performed by canonical correlation analysis (CCA). Finally, the features of EOG and EEG are classified using a relevant vector machine (RVM). Twenty-two subjects participated in the driving fatigue experiments for a duration of 90 min. The results demonstrated that the fusion entropy analysis combining EOG and EEG could provide an alternative method for driving fatigue detection, and the average accuracy rate was up to 99.1 ± 1.2%. The authors further analyzed the effect of feature fusion in four sub-bands (δ, α, β, and θ) and compared with every single sub-band on classification performance, it is proved that the former is superior to the latter presenting the proposed method can provide effective indicators for driving fatigue detection. INDEX TERMSDriving fatigue, electroencephalogram (EEG), electrooculogram (EOG), sample entropy, approximate entropy, spectral entropy.

Fatigue Detection in SSVEP-BCIs Based on Wavelet Entropy of EEG

“…The study [28] applied the multiscale entropy (MSE) to evaluate fatigue in a SSVEP-BCI task and achieved an accuracy rate up to 97%. In [32], multiple entropy calculation methods combined EEG and EOG were applied to the driving fatigue classification, resulting an average accuracy rate round 99%, [33] combined multiple EEG channels and various entropy calculation together, hit the highest accuracy of 97.5% for driving fatigue detection. Those methodologies can provide good classification performance.…”

Diverse Feature Blend Based on Filter-Bank Common Spatial Pattern and Brain Functional Connectivity for Multiple Motor Imagery Detection

“…In addition, to measure the complexity of EEG time series, Wang et al proposed a fusion entropy (sample entropy, approximate entropy, and spectral entropy) analysis method for EEG and EOG signals. Results showed that the average accuracy of the fusion entropy analysis method combined with EOG and EEG can reach 99.1±1.2% [43]. Furthermore, Zhu et al discussed the performance of multi-user MI-BCI idle detection based on common spatial pattern (CSP) and brain network features and proposed several cross-training feature fusion strategies [31].…”

A Method for Interval Prediction of Satellite Battery State of Health Based on Sample Entropy

“…The internal complexity of a lithium-ion battery varies with the degradation of the battery; thus, the SampEn of the voltage sequence could be an effective signature correlated to battery health. At present, SampEn has been applied in the analysis of wind-power generation, heat-exchange performance, heart-rate variability, and time series of diagnostic cases [43]- [45].…”