Driving Distance and Food Accessibility: A Geospatial Analysis of the Food Environment in the Navajo Nation and Border Towns

Abstract

The Navajo Nation, an area home to approximately 173,000 people in the southwest United States, experiences the highest rates of food insecurity in the United States and is classified as a food desert. The present study assessed the accessibility to food outlets (grocery stores, convenience stores, and restaurants) as measured by driving time on the Navajo Nation and in selected surrounding border towns. Food outlets located in neighboring border towns were examined using network analysis tools in ArcGIS Pro to calculate driving distance and examine the potential impact of driving time within the Navajo Nation on accessibility to nutritious foods. There were 14 grocery stores, 21 convenience stores, and 65 restaurants identified in the Navajo Nation using Mergent Intellect, a proprietary database, as compared to border towns which had a total of 542 grocery stores, 762 convenience stores, and 3,329 restaurants equaling a ratio of about 50:1 (grocery, 39:1; convenience, 36:1; restaurants, 51:1) when comparing food outlets nearby versus on the Navajo Nation. This ecological study presents a visual representation of driving time and food accessibility, revealing geographic areas within the Navajo Nation where access to border town food stores is sparse, and food insecurity may be elevated.

Expanding the Baseline: Community Perspectives on Equity in Land-Based Wind Energy Development and Operations

“…One participant shared that over 6,000 Navajo families were experiencing food insecurity in the region. (While NREL's background research did not find the source for this specific statistic, there is abundant documentation of food insecurity throughout Navajo Nation and in Navajo-majority communities [Bennion et al 2022]). Though they trusted some local government leaders, participants worried that a large, government-managed wind energy development would lead to a similarly inequitable situation, and they "don't want to help get someone else rich."…”

Life Space and Activity Space Measurement: Making “Room” for Structural Racism

“…On the other hand, centuries of federal policies steeped in structural racism have resulted in American Indian and Alaska Native communities that are drastically underresourced, with many reservations lacking in basic public services considered essential for day-to-day living. Poor-quality roads and few reliable public transportation options create tangible limitations to movement for many Native American Elders, particularly for those living in rural and frontier regions of the United States ( Bennion et al, 2022 ; Sommerfeld et al, 2021 ). Even basic infrastructure considerations such as funding for animal control services on reservation lands create substantial limitations in movement for Native American Elders.…”