Drawings of Blood Cells Reveal People’s Perception of Their Blood Disorder: A Pilot Study

Abstract

ContextSickle cell disease (SCD) and thalassemia are rare but chronic blood disorders. Recent literature showed impaired quality of life (QOL) in people with these blood disorders. Assessing one of the determinants of QOL (i.e. illness perceptions) therefore, is an important next research area.ObjectiveWe aimed to explore illness perceptions of people with a blood disorder with drawings in addition to the Brief Illness Perception Questionnaire (Brief IPQ). Drawings are a novel method to assess illness perceptions and the free-range answers drawings offer can add additional insight into how people perceive their illness.MethodWe conducted a cross-sectional study including 17 participants with a blood disorder. Participants’ illness perceptions were assessed by the Brief IPQ and drawings. Brief IPQ scores were compared with reference groups from the literature (i.e. people with asthma or lupus erythematosus).ResultsParticipants with SCD or thalassemia perceived their blood disorder as being more chronic and reported more severe symptoms than people with either asthma or lupus erythematosus. In the drawings of these participants with a blood disorder, a greater number of blood cells drawn was negatively correlated with perceived personal control (P<0.05), indicating that a greater quantity in the drawing is associated with more negative or distressing beliefs.ConclusionParticipants with a blood disorder perceive their disease as fairly threatening compared with people with other chronic illnesses. Drawings can add additional insight into how people perceive their illness by offering free-range answers.

Disease Knowledge, Illness Perceptions, and Quality of Life in Adolescents With Sickle Cell Disease: Is There a Link?

“… 12 They report many emotional disturbances such as being distressed by others’ perceptions of their illness, feeling embarrassed, and socially excluded. Ramondt et al 56 have used drawing to determine patients’ perceptions and report that patients feel their illness is chronic and severe, and those drawing more abnormal cells have poorly perceived personal control and greater emotional distress, which is associated with poor control of their illness. Use of drawings may be an important tool to assess patient perceptions and needs further work in this particular population.…”

“Picture this”- Patients’ Drawings of Non-Muscle Invasive Bladder Cancer: A Novel Method to Help Understand How Patients Perceive Their Condition

“…patient's drawings of their condition have been proposed [13,14], on the basis this may afford the opportunity to uncover idiosyncratic beliefs not readily accessible through more standard verbalising methods used in questionnaires or interviews. A num-87 ber of studies reviewed by Broadbent and colleagues 88 [13] have utilised patients' drawings as a method to cause related to the illness and asks participants to ies [17][18][19] participants were informed that "drawing talent" was not important and that a "simple sketch" 176 would also be fine. The drawings were completed by 177 81% (n = 96) of participants.…”

Looking bad: Female patients drawing their representation of chemotherapy-induced alopecia

“…A relatively novel method to assess this perception is the use of drawings as already done in for example, diabetes, sickle cell disease or lung cancer. Drawings show the patients’ uncensored view, contribute to additional insight in the perception of the illness, and show great variety in this perception among patients (Broadbent et al, 2009; Hoogerwerf et al, 2012; Nowicka-Sauer, 2007; Ramondt et al, 2016). In addition, drawings overcome the limitation of predetermined categories in questionnaires (Kaptein et al, 2017; Nowicka-Sauer, 2007; Ramondt et al, 2016).…”