Internal resorption (IR), a rare phenomenon, is considered to be a catch-22 situation from the standpoints of both its diagnosis and treatment. It begins initially in the pulpal space and extends into the surrounding dentin. Its diagnosis and management have been a challenge to dental practitioners. Due to its insidious pathology, IR can progress to a great extent before its detection. It is usually asymptomatic and discovered by chance on routine radiographic examinations or by a classic clinical sign, "pink spot" in the crown. The treatment of this condition should be initiated as soon as possible to prevent further loss of hard tissue or an eventual root perforation. The resorption, if progressed to involve an external communication, has poor prognosis, and the tooth cannot be retained in most cases, and hence, extraction of the tooth is indicated. In modern dentistry, patients demand more than restoration of function; they are particular about the esthetics as well, especially in the anterior region. Once the proper diagnosis is made, the treatment modality should include steps taken to conserve the tooth structure as much as possible to restore tooth form, function, and esthetics. This case report describes the management of an IR of a maxillary central incisor that was treated nonsurgically with conventional root canal treatment followed by reinforcing the tooth with esthetic fiber post and conserving the natural tooth as such. A 9-month follow-up demonstrated clinically asymptomatic and adequately functional tooth, with radiographic signs of healing. In this case report, care was taken to conserve the tooth structure and avoid further weakening of the already compromised tooth. A tooth deemed having questionable prognosis was preserved intact and showed satisfactory healing with no progression of the resorptive defect.