Double-edged sword: persistent effects of Communist regime affiliations on well-being and preferences

Abstract

During Communism, party members and their relatives were typically privileged elites in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) and the former Soviet Union (FSU). At the same time, secret police informants were often coerced to spy and report on their fellow citizens. After the fall of Communism, CEE countries and the Baltics underwent decommunization, unlike most FSU countries. This paper is the first to empirically distinguish between these two Communist party regime affiliations and study their long-term implications for the well-being and preferences of affiliated individuals and their relatives. In the FSU, we find that individuals connected to the former Communist party are more satisfied with their lives, but those linked to secret police informants seem to have lower life satisfaction than those without such ties. The life satisfaction benefit of having former Communist regime party connections in the FSU is, on average, equivalent to one month’s household income. Simultaneously, the psychological costs of being an informant can amount to two monthly household incomes. In CEE countries, having informant connections is not associated with life satisfaction, but having links to the former Communist party is negatively correlated with subjective well-being. Formal and informal decommunization efforts are an important mechanism behind our findings. We also show that those connected to the former regimes differ from those without such connections in their preferences for democracy and market economy, levels of optimism, and risk tolerance, which provides suggestive evidence for the mechanisms underpinning our findings. Our results underscore that the former Communist regimes produced winners and losers based on the trustee status of their collaborators that decommunization efforts further shaped and solidified. Future decommunization efforts in the FSU may thus have important welfare implications.

Political orientation and education investment: an OECD perspective

“…42 Bugajski (2020); Williams and Ishiyama (2018). 43 Frye (2012); Otrachshenko et al (2023). 44 Burnside and Dollar (2000).…”

Children of Communism: Former Party Membership and the Demand for Redistribution

“…In particular, they were likely to be better familiar with the wide differences in the access to goods and services between the privileged nomenklatura groups and the rest of the population (Matthews 2011;Filtzer 2014). De-facto practices of interaction within the party were likely to have a strong socializing effect on its members, but they produced a very different socialization effect than the one the regime would prefer: disillusionment, opportunism, cynicism, and willingness to adapt to the existing environment, as well as better ability to network and to acquire connections necessary for a successful career (Bahry and Silver 1990;Harris 1986;Niethammer 1990;Titma et al 2004;Libman and Obydenkova 2021;Otrachshenko et al 2023). These 'opportunistic' Communists should at the very least not differ in terms of preferences for redistribution from the rest of the population.…”

The Societal Costs of Inflation and Unemployment

“…While neoclassical economics predicts that inflation is not substantively harmful to individuals, evidence suggests that people strongly dislike inflation (Shiller, 1997), giving rise to a splintered view among economists about the actual economic, cognitive, and social costs 1 Social trust is at the core of financial transactions and economic exchange (Arrow, 1972) and is linked with economic growth and prosperity (Akçomak and Ter Weel, 2009;Algan and Cahuc, 2010;Knack and Keefer, 1997;Tabellini, 2010). The determinants of social trust include genetic diversity, governance status, political affiliations, conflicts, and repressions, among others (Ashraf and Galor, 2013;Bai and Wu, 2020;Conzo and Salustri, 2019;Guiso et al, 2016;Nikolova, Popova, and Otrachshenko, 2022;Nunn and Wantchekon, 2011;Otrachshenko, Nikolova, and Popova, 2023).…”