“…Because of the metastable nature of Sn 2+ , which has an electronic configuration of [Kr]4 d 10 5 s 2 , some Sn 2+ -based oxides have only marginal phase stabilities, , which may induce difficulties in intentional chemical doping. , In contrast, Bi 3+ -based oxides are rather stable because of the stability of Bi 3+ , which has an electronic configuration of [Xe]5 d 10 6 s 2 . Another grouping is based on the dimensionality of the crystal structure, namely, three-dimensional (3D) structures, such as pyrochlore and double-perovskite structures, − or two-dimensional (2D) layered structures. − It has been determined experimentally and theoretically , that oxygen vacancies ( V O ), which generate electrons and electrically compensate for holes, tend to form more easily in 3D oxides than in 2D oxides. Consequently, the hole generation efficiencies (η), which is defined as the ratio between the appeared hole carrier density and acceptor density, of 2D Sn 2+ -oxides (1.4–1.7%) are greater than those of 3D Sn 2+ -oxides (0.03–0.005%), , whereas those of the acceptor-ion-doped 3D Bi 3+ -oxides are extremely low (0.0003–0.001%). ,, …”