Allograft transplantation requires chronic immunosuppression, but there is no effective strategy to evaluate the long-term maintenance of immunosuppression other than assessment of graft function. The ability to monitor naive alloreactive T cells would provide an alternative guide for drug therapy at early, preclinical stages of graft rejection and for evaluating tolerance-inducing protocols. To detect and quantify naive alloreactive T cells directly ex vivo, we used the unique ability of naive T cells to rapidly produce TNF-␣ but not IFN-␥. Naive alloreactive T cells were identified by the production of TNF-␣ after a 5-hour in vitro stimulation with alloantigen and were distinguished from effector/memory alloreactive T cells by the inability to produce IFN-␥. Moreover, naive alloreactive T cells were not detected in mice tolerized against specific alloantigens. The frequency of TNF-␣-producing cells was predictive for rejection in an in vivo cytotoxicity assay and correlated with skin allograft rejection. Naive alloreactive T cells were also detected in humans, suggesting clinical relevance. We conclude that rapid production of TNF-␣ can be used to quantify naive alloreactive T cells, that it is abrogated after the induction of tolerance, and that it is a potential tool to predict allograft rejection.
IntroductionThe ability to reject allografts is a hallmark of the immune system and is mediated by the vigorous immune response generated against MHC-disparate haplotypes. To prevent allograft rejection in patients undergoing transplantation, chronic immunosuppressive drug therapy is required. [1][2][3] Clinical parameters of graft function currently guide drug choice and dosage during immunosuppressive therapy, but significant organ damage can occur prior to recognition of ongoing but subclinical graft rejection. The ability to identify and quantify alloreactive T cells prior to the appearance of clinical signs of graft rejection could improve patient management or the use of immunosuppressive drugs for maintaining allograft survival. A protocol to rapidly quantify naive and effector/memory alloreactive T cells could also be used to evaluate tolerance induction protocols as they enter clinical transplantation trials. [4][5][6] T cells are an important component of allograft rejection, and alloreactive T cells represent a substantial proportion of the naive T-cell repertoire. Between 0.1% and 10% of naive T cells within an individual are estimated to be reactive with any unique allogeneic MHC haplotype. [7][8][9][10] Assays that have been used to quantify alloreactive T cells, including limiting dilution analysis, 11,12 enzymelinked immunospot assays, [13][14][15][16] and in vivo proliferation assays, 10,13,15,17 require an extended in vitro culture period. However, these assays have not been translated effectively into the clinic and do not permit direct and rapid identification of naive alloreactive T cells.Naive T cells are thought to acquire full functionality only after a programmed pathway of differentiatio...