Electrocatalytic energy conversion driven by renewably generated electricity is a key technology to achieve a sustainable society in the future, namely, CO 2 reduction and hydrogen production. Despite increasing research efforts dedicated to these reactions, there is no consensus regarding the proton source directly participating in surface reactions under nonacidic pH conditions: Free proton (H + ) versus proton-containing species (e. g., H 2 O, H x PO 4 xÀ 3 , H y CO 3 yÀ 2). We herein addressed this issue by rigorously quantifying the diffusion flux and protolysis rate during the aqueous hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Our analysis revealed that there exists the linear free-energy relationship (LFER) between the pK a and the rate of protolysis (HA!H + + A À ). Furthermore, the diffusion flux of the free proton as a consequence of the mass transport and protolysis failed to account for the typical current density of interest on the order of À 10 mA cm À 2 at non-acidic pH levels when the K a value and the molarity of the buffering species were low; e. g., < À 0.1 mA cm À 2 was attainable at pH > 5 in 1.0 M KHCO 3 (pK a = 10.3). As a result, under such circumstance, the protoncontaining species is suggested to directly react on the surface during the cathodic electrocatalytic reactions.