Domestic Violence in Separated Couples in Italian Context: Communalities and Singularities of Women and Men Experiences

Abstract

Relationship breakdown and separation represent a critical aspect in domestic violence. Few studies have investigated domestic violence in separated couples. Moreover, there is a need for a more in depth analysis of gender differences that could enhance the comprehension of the phenomenon. The primary aim of this research was to analyze, through a qualitative approach, which kinds of domestic violence are characteristic or major in separated couples in the Italian context, where this phenomenon has not yet been sufficiently investigated. Participants are 60 separated couples (mean age: M = 48; F = 44) who attended a Family Mediation Center. A descriptive study was conducted using grounded theory methodology. A brief narrative task was administered to both ex-partners separately. The transcriptions were analyzed using NVivo 11 software. From data analysis, some themes emerged regarding typology of domestic violence specific of the separation context and shared by both men and women. The analyses of gender differences showed that there is a gender specific experience of domestic violence. Results highlight that women narrate both physical and psychological violence, while men relate only psychological abuse focused on limiting access to children. We discuss these findings in relation to possible appropriate gender specific intervention and prevention efforts.

Through a relational lens: reflections about foster care experience in Italian emancipated foster youth

“…Moving on negative relational outcome, it is interesting to note that the results of category bad memories underline a gender difference about maltreatment recollection because this memory is reported only by women. This result is in line with previous research that underlines how women have often been considered to be the predominant victims ( Cardinali et al, 2018 ), but this could also be associated with men’s difficulties to report these experiences in the Italian cultural and social context where for a man, reporting intimate partner violence behavior might induce shame, guilt, and embarrassment, which possibly decreases the likelihood of disclosure of such violence ( Felson and Paré, 2005 ).…”

Prevalence of Domestic Violence against Women and Its Visibility in Southeast Iran

“…Although it is felt that terminating undesirable marriages puts an end to the DVAW, this is not the case in reality. Divorced women, despite being separated from their husbands, are still abused often by their ex-husbands ( 28 ).…”

Approaches to the study of "domestic violence" in the works of Western and Arab researchers

“…P. Cardinali, L. Migliorini, F. Giribone, F. Bizzi, and D. Cavanna, presented the kinds of domestic violence which are characteristic or major in separated couples in the Italian context. where, women narrate both physical and psychological violence, while men narrate only psychological abuse focused on limiting access to children [6]. Disclosure of victims of domestic violence in public health and mental health institutions helps to provide optimal care of vulnerable people [7] [8].…”