Does the time of day in orthopedic trauma surgery affect mortality and complication rates?

Abstract

BackgroundOrthopedic trauma surgery has multiple, both patient-based and surgeon-based risk factors. Evaluating and modifying certain patient safety factors could mitigate some of these risks. This study investigates the influence that the time of day of surgery has on mortality and complication rates.Question/purposeThis study evaluates whether the time of day of orthopedic trauma surgery influences complication or mortality rates.Patients and methodsA prospective Swiss surgical database developed as a nationwide quality assurance project was reviewed retrospectively. All patients with trauma-coded diagnoses that were surgically treated in Swiss hospitals between 2004 and 2014 were evaluated. Surgery times were stratified into morning, afternoon, evening and night. The primary outcomes were in-hospital mortality and complication rates. Co-factors were sought in bivariate and multivariable analysis.ResultsOf 31,692 patients, 13,969 (44.3%) were operated in the morning, 12,696 (40.3%) in the afternoon, 4,331 (13.7%) in the evening, and 550 (1.7%) at night. Mortality rates were significantly higher in nighttime (2.4%, OR 1.26, p=0.04) and afternoon surgery (1.7%, OR 1.94, p=0.03) vs. surgery in the morning (1.1%). Surgery performed in the afternoon and at night showed significantly increased general complication rates vs. surgery performed in the morning. (OR 1.22, p=0.006 and OR 1.51, p=0.021, respectively).ConclusionThis study observed higher complication and mortality rates for surgery performed after-hours, which correlates with other recent studies. Surgeon fatigue is a potential contributing factor for these increased risks. Other potential factors include surgeon experience, surgery type, and the potential for more severe or emergent injuries occurring after-hours.

Impact of Regional Block Failure in Ambulatory Hand Surgery on Patient Management: A Cohort Study

“…Beyond the statistical question, this means the number of patients that need to be treated (i.e., switched from a conventional to an ambulatory surgical unit) to avoid one additional failure would be 2.9 (95% CI: 1.4, 7.5). We suggest that operating on ambulatory patients outside of regular hours may increase the postoperative morbidity, as already described for other procedures [15,16].…”

Time of day does not influence outcomes in acute type A aortic dissection: Results from the IRAD

“…Multiple studies have shown inferior outcomes for surgical procedures during evening hours. [1][2][3][4] However, findings of increased surgical morbidity and mortality during evening hours are by no means universal, as some data show no difference in outcomes for surgical procedures during evening hours. [5][6][7][8][9] The relevance to the public health community for maintaining patient safety during surgery, despite evening operative hours, cannot be overstated.…”

A Randomized Controlled Study on the Safety and Effectiveness of Total Knee Arthroplasty Operated At Different Times under ERASA.

“…al. found that night surgery is less effective than day surgery and morning is better than an afternoon (16). But Montaigne et al found that in cardiac surgery, afternoon surgery is more effective (7).In two independent studies, Kelz et al Found (7)(8)(9).…”