Does surgical stabilization improve outcomes in patients with isolated multiple distracted and painful non-flail rib fractures?

Abstract

A best evidence topic was constructed according to a structured protocol. The question addressed was whether surgical stabilization is effective in improving the outcomes of patients with isolated multiple distracted and painful non-flail rib fractures. Of the 356 papers found using a report search, nine presented the best evidence to answer the clinical question. The authors, journal, date and country of publication, study type, group studied, relevant outcomes and results of these papers are given. We conclude that, on the whole, the nine retrieved studies clearly support the use of surgical stabilization in the management of isolated multiple non-flail and painful rib fractures for improving patient outcomes. The interest and benefit was shown not only in terms of pain (McGill pain questionnaire) and respiratory function (forced vital capacity, forced expiratory volume in 1 s and carbon monoxide diffusing capacity), but also in improved quality of life (RAND 36-Item Health Survey) and reduced socio-professional disability. Indeed, most of the authors justified surgical management based on the fact that the results of surgical stabilization showed improvement in short- and long-term patient outcomes, with fast reduction in pain and disability, as well as lower average wait before recommencing normal activities. Hence, the current evidence shows surgical stabilization to be safe and effective in alleviating post-operative pain and in improving patient recovery, thus enhancing the outcome after isolated multiple rib fractures. However, given the little published evidence, prospective trials are necessary to confirm these encouraging results.

Pain Managment of Multiple Rib Fractures on the Basis of Early Reduction and Fixation in Patients without Intensive Care Unit.

“…In our study, we found a difference between the early surgery group and conservative follow up group in favor of the surgery (p= 0.020). The rate of pneumonia in these patients who did not require intensive care support was much lower than the patients who did not undergo surgery [8,19,20]. However, these studies generally include ICU patients and as we mentioned before, these patients have different risks and intensive care support is a predisposing factor for septic complications.…”

Role of surgical fixation in rib fractures: an experimental study

“…We think the health status of the group III is better than the other groups. There are texts in the literature recommending rib fixation to reduce the pain of the patient if the fracture ends are moving in multiple and displaced rib fractures, even if they do not have flail chest [18].…”

Sternal pseudoarthrosis after resternotomy treated with the Strasbourg Thoracic Osteosyntheses System: a case report

“…Titanium can integrate with bone. This is reliant on osteoblasts attaching to the titanium surface and eventually forming mineralized bone in continuity with the implant, which then is less likely to "loosen" over time (9,11).…”