Does Online Newsmedia Portrayal of Substance Use and Persons with Substance Misuse Endorse Stigma? A Qualitative Study from India

Abstract

Media provides and shapes public knowledge, perceptions, and attitude towards people with substance misuse. We aimed to explore the content and specific themes of Indian online news articles on substance use or persons with substance misuse. We followed an exploratory qualitative design to analyze online news media reports published between July 1 2020 and June 30 2021. Hundred articles met the selection criteria. Our content analysis was based on a checklist. Thematic analysis was done by the coding, categorization, and theme generation after meticulous data immersion and triangulation. Sixty percent of articles had pessimistic headlines and portrayed substance use or persons with substance use negatively. Fifty-one percent articles were on alcohol. Twenty-seven percent articles focussed supply reduction, whereas only 5% positively discussed the role of treatment. We identified seven themes. Most frequent themes were legal-criminal aspects of substance use ( n = 39), psychosocial and health hazards of substance use ( n = 30), and propagation of public stigma ( n = 25). Two other prevalent themes were the business and marketing of alcohol ( n = 20) and sociocultural aspects of substance use ( n = 9). The theme, treatment strategy, appeared in only five articles. There is an urgent need for media guidelines for responsible reporting of substance misuse. We suggested a set of recommendations for media reporting.

Stigma toward substance use disorders: a multinational perspective and call for action

“…One systematic thematic analysis of Indian newspaper articles explored online media’s attitudes and perceptions toward individuals with SUDs. Results showed that many articles propagated public stigma by using stigmatizing language, identifying people who use drugs with negative and unwanted qualities ( 10 ). Similarly, the media in New Zealand had often used terms such as “meth head” and “drug addict” when discussing individuals with SUDs ( 11 ).…”

Effects of media representations of drug related deaths on public stigma and support for harm reduction

“…There have been no empirical studies of the effects of news media representation of DRD on public attitudes towards PWUD, or support for drug policy. Other work has shown that media representations of PWUD more generally may be an important determinant of public stigma ( Atkinson, et al, 2019 ;Atkinson & Sumnall, 2018Belackova, Stastna, & Miovsky, 2011 ;Ghosh, et al, 2022 ;. Public stigma refers to stereotypes, negative attitudes and beliefs held by members of the public about people with devalued characteristics, and which may motivate fear, avoidance, and discrimination ( Corrigan & Rao, 2012 ).…”