Does Marriage Make Us Healthier? Inter-Country Comparative Evidence from China, Japan, and Korea

Abstract

ObjectivesThis study focuses on East Asian countries and investigates the difference in the marriage premium on the health-marriage protection effect (MPE) between younger and older generations and the intra-couple education concordance effect (ECE) on the health of married individuals. This study used inter-country comparative data from China, Japan, and Korea.MethodsThis study focused on individuals (n = 7,938) in China, Japan, and Korea who were sampled from the 2010 East Asian Social Survey. To investigate MPE and ECE, four health indicators were utilized: a physical and mental components summary (PCS and MCS), self-rated health status (Dself), and happiness level (Dhappy). Ordinary least squares regression was conducted by country- and gender-specific subsamples.ResultsWe found that the MPE on PCS, MCS, and Dself was more significant for the older generation than for the younger generation in both China and Japan, whereas the results were inconclusive in Korea. With regard to the ECE on happiness (Dhappy), for both men and women, couples tend to be happier when both the husband and the wife are well educated (“higher balanced marriage”) compared to couples with a lower level of educational achievement (“lower balanced marriage”). Significant benefits from a “higher balanced marriage” on MCS and Dself were observed for women only. In contrast, no statistically significant differences in health status were observed between “higher balanced marriage” couples and couples with different levels of educational achievements (“upward marriage” or “downward marriage”).ConclusionsThis study found that (1) the MPE was more significant for the older generation, and (2) the health gap, particularly the happiness gap, between higher- and lower-balanced married couples was significant. The inter-country comparative findings are useful to explain how the role of marriage (and therefore of family) on health has been diluted due to the progress of industrialization and modernization.

Social-Demographic Correlates of the Mental Health Conditions among the Chinese Elderly

“…Marital status and living arrangement are other important factors influencing the mental health of the elderly. Our study showed that single/divorced/widowed persons and those living alone were more likely to suffer from mental problems, which are consistent with the findings from other studies [30,32,33]. In addition, this may be attributed to the changes of family structure from a multi-child family to a single-child one.…”

Prevalence and correlates of psychological distress among diabetes mellitus adults in the Jilin province in China: a cross-sectional study

“…Many researchers concluded that marriage has a protective effect on mental health (Fu & Noguchi, 2016; Hughes & Waite, 2009). In our study, divorce or separation from one’s spouse is the most significant factor associated with psychological distress.…”

Subjective Happiness, Health and Quality of Life and Their Sociocultural Correlates among Younger Population in Malawi

“…Thus, it is assumable that marital status among the younger population may not result in better health and happiness. The diminishing role on better health outcomes in the context of progressive industrialisation and modernisation have been reported in several Asian countries as well (Fu and Noguchi 2016). As countries in Africa continue to embrace modern lifestyles and culture characteristics of Western countries, exploring the dynamics of family, marriage, and fertility can be rewarding in terms of promoting evidence for better psychosocial health of the population.…”