Does female board representation influence firm performance? The Danish evidence

Abstract

Board diversity has become a major issue within corporate governance where a number of studies seek to explore the impact of diversity on firm performance. The debate focuses on questions such as whether a corporation's board should reflect the firm's stakeholders or be more in line with society in general. This article uses a sample of listed Danish firms during the period of 1998-2001 in a cross sectional analysis. Despite that fact that Denmark has gone very far in the liberalisation of women, Danish board rooms are still to a large extent dominated by men. Contrary to a number of other studies, this article does not find any significant link between firm performance as measured by Tobin's Q and female board representation. This is also the case for board members' educational background as well as the proportion of foreigners. It is argued that board members with an unconventional background are socialised unconsciously adopting the ideas of the majority of conventional board members, which entails that a potential performance effect does not materialise. Copyright (c) 2007 The Author; Journal compilation (c) 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd.

Entrepreneurial orientation and firm performance in family SMEs: the moderating effects of family, women, and strategic involvement in the board of directors

“…There is an ongoing debate about whether female representation on boards adds value by improving firm outcomes (Campbell and Minguez-Vera 2008), has a detrimental effect on firm value (Adams and Ferreira 2009), or has no impact on firm performance Rose 2007). These inconsistent results, in addition to the fact that relatively little research links gender diversity and board process tasks, makes more research necessary (Wilson et al 2013).…”

“…Boards with high strategic involvement may have more alternatives to evaluate during the problem-solving process (Rose 2007) due to the active involvement of diverse board members (Machold et al 2011) during which female directors may contribute their unique knowledge, perspectives, and skills (Chapple and Humphrey, 2014). Further, a high SIBD may help firms design successful responses to current and new customer needs (Groysberg and Bell 2013) due to women directors' stronger marketing and sales abilities (Ali et al 2014).…”

Board diversity and firm performance: The Indonesian evidence

“…Bär et al (2008) indicate a negative relation between gender diversity of the management team and fund returns, using a sample from US mutual fund industry. Some researchers are unable to find a significant association between gender diversity and financial performance, such as Dwyer et al (2003), Randøy et al (2006), Rose (2007), and Marinova et al (2010). Using a small sample consisting of 42 Indonesian manufacturing companies, Kusumastuti et al (2007) find no empirical relationship between female directors and Tobin's q.…”

The Effect of Board Diversity on the Performance of Banks: Evidence from Turkey

“…Moreover, heterogeneous boards can bring alternative perspectives on various issues and greater access to information resulting in creative problem solving (Erhardt, Werbel, & Shrader, 2003). In addition, a higher degree of diversity in a company's board may send a positive signal to potential job applicants and other stakeholders, such as consumers, suppliers, and the community (Rose, 2007). Hence, a gender and racially diverse board signals that the firm may meet the needs of a diverse market place, understand the business environment, and advise the firm executives effectively (Miller & Triana, 2009).…”