Does Confucianism allow for body donation?

Abstract

Confucianism has been widely perceived as a major moral and cultural obstacle to the donation of bodies for anatomical purposes. The rationale for this is the Confucian stress on xiao (filial piety), whereby individuals' bodies are to be intact at death. In the view of many, the result is a prohibition on the donation of bodies to anatomy departments for the purpose of dissection. The role of dissection throughout the development of anatomy within a Confucian context is traced, and in contemporary China the establishment of donation programs and the appearance of memorial monuments is noted. In reassessing Confucian attitudes, the stress laid on a particular interpretation of filial piety is questioned, and an attempt is made to balance this with the Confucian emphasis on a moral duty to those outside one's immediate family. The authors argue that the fundamental Confucian norm ren (humaneness or benevolence) allows for body donation as people have a moral duty to help others. Moreover, the other central Confucian value, li (rites), offers important insights on how body donation should be performed as a communal activity, particularly the necessity of developing ethically and culturally appropriate rituals for body donation. In seeking to learn from this from a Western perspective, it is contended that in all societies the voluntary donation of bodies is a deeply human activity that is to reflect the characteristics of the community within which it takes place. This is in large part because it has educational and personal repercussions for students. Anat Sci Educ 11: 525-531. © 2018 American Association of Anatomists.

Making the Ethical Transition in South Africa: Acquiring Human Bodies for Training in Anatomy

“…The concept of ancestors ( izinyanya ) and joining the spiritual world (Kometsi and Louw, ) has been shown to have a negative impact on organ donation and on the dissection of the human body. This is in direct contrast to the Buddhist philosophy where body donation is seen as altruistic (Subasinghe and Jones, ; Jones and Nie), the donor has high status and is named “ajarn yai” (great teacher) (Winkelmann and Güldner, ).…”

Body Donation in Beijing, China in the Last 20 Years: Current Status and Future Development

“…Additionally, a "Medical Ethics Education Center," accompanied by a series of donor gratitude events, was established in Nanjing (Zhang et al, 2014). The influence of Confucianism on willed body donation programs in China was also examined based on historical context (Jones and Nie, 2018). The relationship between brain donation for human brain banking and body donation in PUMC was investigated recently .…”

Creating a Human Gross Anatomy Laboratory: The Experience at a Primarily Undergraduate Institution

“…Another important consideration with regard to the sustainability of a laboratory is the availability of human donor bodies. The availability of human donors can vary due to social, legal, religious, and geographical factors (Santibañez et al, 2016;Jones and Nie, 2018;Saw, 2018;Techataweewan et al, 2018;Gürses et al, 2019). For example, the cadaveric dissection program at The National University of Singapore stopped as a result of limited cadaver supply but was subsequently revived as a result of "silent mentor" body donation (Saw, 2018), in accordance with the Buddhist Tzu Chi Silent Mentor Program which promoted the donation of one's body to science as an act of selflessness (and has subsequently increased donations in several countries) (Santibañez et al, 2016;Saw, 2018).…”