Does antibiotic use accelerate or retard cutaneous repair? A systematic review in animal models

Abstract

BackgroundThe presence of infections is one of the main factors that leads to delays in healing or non-closure of cutaneous wounds. Although the goal of antibiotic use is to treat or prevent infection, there is currently no agreement on the effectiveness of these products.AimThe aim of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of antibiotic use during the healing process of skin wounds in animal models not intentionally infected, as well as to analyze the advances and limitations of the studies carried out in this field.Main methodsThis systematic review was performed according to the PRISMA guidelines, using a structured search on the MedLine (PubMed) and Scopus platforms to retrieve studies published until August 29, 2018, 13:35p.m. The studies included were limited to those that used excision or incision wound models and that were not intentionally infected. The data for the animal models, antibiotic used, and the main results of the studies were extracted, and compared where possible. Bias analysis and methodological quality assessments were examined through the SYRCLE’s Risk of Bias tool.Key findingsTwenty-seven studies were selected. Overall, the effects of the antibiotic on the wound decreased inflammatory cell infiltration and promoted an increased number of fibroblasts, extracellular matrix constituents, re-epithelialization and tissue strength. A great deal of important information about the methodology was not presented, such as: the statistical analysis used, the animal model (sex and age), antibiotic dosage, blinding and randomization of the animals chosen.SignificanceBased on the results found, we believe that antibiotic therapy can be considered a viable alternative for the treatment of cutaneous wounds. However, current evidence obtained from the methodological quality analysis points towards a high risk of bias. This is due to the incomplete characterization of the experimental design and treatment protocol, which compromises the reproducibility of the studies.

Mechanical induced wounds in fish – a review on models and healing mechanisms

“…A large review on antibiotic use in mammals also concluded that antibiotics to treat wounds should only be used when there is a risk of infection and not as an elective therapy for wound treatment (Altoé et al . 2019).…”

Effects of the amount and type of carbohydrates used in type 2 diabetes diets in animal models: A systematic review

“…Studies were also divided according to the type of carbohydrate (sucrose, glucose, fructose, fiber, resistant starch) and glycaemic index, when available. Data were subsequently compared and conflicting information was identified and corrected after discussion among the reviewers [17].…”

“…The items in the RoB tool were scored with "yes" (low risk of bias); "no" (high risk of bias); or "unclear" (indicating that the item was not reported, and therefore, the risk of bias was unknown) [12]. The items in the RoB tool were scored with "yes" (low risk of bias); "no" (high risk of bias); or "unclear" (indicating that the item was not reported, and therefore, the risk of bias was unknown) [17].…”

Comparison of the effectiveness of Aloe Vera Gel with 2% Nitrofurazone ointment on the healing of superficial second-degree burns. Randomised clinical trial

“…Alongside with a large number of studies stating that Aloe Vera improve (30,(40)(41)(42)(43) and accelerates (44)(45)(46) the healing process and epithelialization, a study, published in 2019, states that nitrofuran drug class diminishes epithelialization of wounds (47).…”