Does Accountability Undermine Service Delivery? The Impact of Devolving Agriculture in Ghana

Abstract

In recent years, many developing countries have devolved services to locally elected governments. Although this may strengthen downwards accountability to citizens, does devolution improve service provision? Ghana began devolving agriculture in 2012 to its Metropolitan, Municipal, and District Assemblies (MMDAs). Drawing on an original survey with 80 District Directors of Agriculture and 960 households, as well as district-level budget data and interviews with national and local government stakeholders, this paper shows that agricultural expenditures and services have been negatively affected by the transition. The imperative of electoral accountability encourages assembly members to de-prioritize agriculture in the budget process in favor of more visible goods and services. Budget allocations, however, do reflect the preferences of local citizens, a majority of whom value using elections to sanction their district politicians. The findings indicate that devolution may increase accountability but result in sectoral trade-offs in service provision, which may undermine national policy objectives.

Akuntabilitas Pelayanan Publik Studi Kasus Pelayanan Perizinan Surat Izin Penelitian Di Bakesbangpol Kota Batu

“…Pada dasarnya, akuntabilitas menuntut pejabat pemerintah untuk menjelaskan tindakan mereka kepada publik dan disertai dengan beberapa bentuk penegakan untuk menghukum kinerja yang buruk. Dengan rasa kepemilikan tanggung jawab penyediaan layanan kepada masyarakat, pemerintah memiliki prioritas penuh untuk warganya (Resnick, 2022).…”

Decentralisation and Central Government Control: Experiences from the Local Government Reform in Zimbabwe

“…Political decentralisation aims to ensure democratic local governance by giving local people and their elected leaders more influence in policy formulation and implementation for their social, political, and economic well-being (Resnick, 2021). Smoke (2003) opines that administrative and fiscal decentralisation are important but cannot achieve the needs of decentralisation and local government reforms in general without adequate political reform.…”

Embracing political economy to enhance policy influence: Lessons from PIM research

“…The low visibility of agricultural extension reflects the fact that it involves the transfer of an intangible item, i.e., knowledge, its benefits are only evident in the longer-term, and attribution is difficult, since the benefits of extension advice can be undermined by bad weather, economic shocks, or improper implementation by smallholders (Anderson 2008). PIM-supported surveys of rural households in Ghana (Resnick 2021) and Nepal (Kyle et al 2017) revealed that, despite low levels of access to extension services, those employed in Relatedly, it can be difficult to gain traction among policymakers for complex, long-term, and/or multisectoral interventions. For example, in Bangladesh and India, PIM researchers examined the prospects for implementation of weather indexbased crop insurance for smallholder farmers.…”