Does a Bioenergetics Model Accurately Predict Fish Consumption by American White Pelicans? A Case Study on Walleyes in the Tamarac River, Minnesota

Abstract

The effect of piscivorous birds on fisheries is a growing concern for fisheries managers, especially when native birds consume large quantities of fish. The Red Lakes, Minnesota, fishery is one such example, where congregations of American white pelicans (AWPEs) Pelecanus erythrorhynchos forage on spawning Walleyes Sander vitreus. We quantified AWPE consumption of Walleyes on the Tamarac River, a major tributary of the Red Lakes, by using empirical diet data collected from lethally sampled birds and separately by using a bioenergetics model. Furthermore, we evaluated the diet and foraging patterns of AWPEs on the river. Camera trap data revealed that AWPEs were foraging nearly completely nocturnally, likely in response to Walleye spawning migrations, with Walleyes accounting for 98% of AWPE diets. The empirical estimate of daily fish consumption from lethally sampled birds was not significantly different from the bioenergetics estimate. Monte Carlo simulations were used to provide estimates of uncertainty in annual Walleye consumption. Based on the simulations, all estimates of annual Walleye consumption between 2014 and 2016 represented < 1% of adult (age ≥ 3) Walleyes in the system and < 2.5% of adult Walleye natural mortality. This amount of Walleye consumption by AWPEs, at current population levels, does not pose a management concern.

Colonial Waterbird Predation and Angler Catch of Hatchery Rainbow Trout Stocked in Southern Idaho Fisheries

“…However, it should be noted that avian predation varied widely among the waterbodies, and occasionally, among years at the same water. Substantial variation in fish predation by colonial waterbirds among waterbodies or years has been observed in previous studies, which have ascribed such variation to differences in foraging distance from the colony (Meyer et al 2016) and environmental conditions that affected the vulnerability of prey (Teuscher et al 2015;Graham et al 2019). Also, in some waterbodies with substantial numbers of colonial waterbirds (e.g., American Falls Reservoir; also see Meyer et al 2016), avian predation of stocked catchables was consistently low, suggesting that birds were targeting other prey.…”

“…; Graham et al. ). Also, in some waterbodies with substantial numbers of colonial waterbirds (e.g., American Falls Reservoir; also see Meyer et al.…”