Doctors’ Extended Shifts as Risk to Practitioner and Patient: South Africa as a Case Study

Abstract

Extended shifts are common in medical practice. This is when doctors are required to work continuously for more than 16 hours, with little or no rest, often without a maximum limit. These shifts have been a part of medical practice for more than a century. Research on the impact of fatigue presents compelling evidence that extended shifts increase the risk of harm to patients and practitioners. However, where the number of doctors is limited and their workloads are not easily reduced, there are numerous barriers to reform. Some of these include a perceived lack of safer alternatives, concerns about continuity of care, trainee education, and doctors’ preferences. As such, working hour reorganisation has been contentious globally. South Africa, a middle-income country where extended shifts are unregulated for most doctors, offers a useful case study of reform efforts. The South African Safe Working Hours campaign has promoted working hour reorganization through multi-level advocacy efforts, although extended shifts remain common. We propose that extended shifts should be regarded as an occupational hazard under health and safety legislation. We suggest options for managing the risks of extended shifts by adapting the hierarchy of controls for occupational hazards. Despite the challenges reform pose, the practice of unregulated extended shifts should not continue.

Private Health Facilities Participation in Comprehensive Health Service

“…The disadvantages of private healthcare are that it is expensive, there are fewer facilities, and patients are responsible for paying for healthcare visits, pharmaceuticals, and additional resources such as wheelchairs. On the other hand, a study by [24] highlighted doctors' extended shifts as a risk to practitioner and patient. It was indicated in this study that getting access to more specialized levels of service depended on referrals.…”

Effect of Workload, Work Shift, and Work Stress on Burnout of General Practitioners at Makassar Regional General Hospital during the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…Research on elongated shifts in doctors has the impact of fatigue, increasing the risk of harm to patients and doctors themselves. This elongated shift is partly due to the lack of doctors working at the hospital (17). The shortage of doctors was found during the COVID-19 pandemic, and the increasing number of patients in hospitals made them overwhelmed and more vulnerable to being infected with COVID-19.…”

Simulation of the Impact on the Workload of the Enlargement of the Clinical Staff of a Specialistic Reference Center

“…The effects of an exaggerated workload for physicians and clinical staff have been widely explored in literature. The quality of care was proved to be negatively impacted by high workloads in terms of clinical outcomes, patient safety and mortality (1)(2)(3), but also the patient-physician interaction and the consequent patient satisfaction (3,4) strongly suffer from high workload. Hence, the quantification of the physicians' workload, along with strategies for reducing it, are issues worth of being explored.…”