Doctors' experience with handheld computers in clinical practice: qualitative study

Abstract

Objective To examine doctors' perspectives about their experiences with handheld computers in clinical practice. Design Qualitative study of eight focus groups consisting of doctors with diverse training and practice patterns. Setting Six practice settings across the United States and two additional focus group sessions held at a national meeting of general internists. Participants 54 doctors who did or did not use handheld computers. Results Doctors who used handheld computers in clinical practice seemed generally satisfied with them and reported diverse patterns of use. Users perceived that the devices helped them increase productivity and improve patient care. Barriers to use concerned the device itself and personal and perceptual constraints, with perceptual factors such as comfort with technology, preference for paper, and the impression that the devices are not easy to use somewhat difficult to overcome. Participants suggested that organisations can help promote handheld computers by providing advice on purchase, usage, training, and user support. Participants expressed concern about reliability and security of the device but were particularly concerned about dependency on the device and over-reliance as a substitute for clinical thinking. Conclusions Doctors expect handheld computers to become more useful, and most seem interested in leveraging (getting the most value from) their use. Key opportunities with handheld computers included their use as a stepping stone to build doctors' comfort with other information technology and ehealth initiatives and providing point of care support that helps improve patient care.

Use of smartphones among medical students in the clinical years at a medical school in Sub-Sahara Africa: A pilot study

“…Provision of smartphones uploaded with clinical decision support software (CDSS) to medical students was associated with increased use in clinical settings and improved knowledge of evidence-based medicine 20 . Resident Doctors who shoulder greater responsibility in patient care consider smartphones an important tool in enhancing productivity, quality of patient care and services 21 .…”

Letters to the Editor

“…PDAs have been in use by doctors for several years (McAlearney et al, 2004;McLeod et al, 2003), but until now there has been no data on PDA use in UK medical students. Using an online questionnaire of all undergraduate medical students in one UK medical school, we undertook an evaluation of PDA usefulness and uptake.…”

Information communications technology in general practice: cross-sectional survey in London

“…The PDA in particular has great potential for use among nurses for prescribing and recording clinical data on home visits, and a recent qualitative study has confirmed that, in the United States at least, there is growing enthusiasm for the use of handheld computers in clinical practice. 15 The potential of the use of this technology by professionals involved in communitybased health care -home visits, chronic illness reviews and palliative care, for example -is enormous, and deserves more research attention.…”

“…This means achieving an understanding of the barriers to the uptake of information technology in healthcare systems, and the means of overcoming them, as a matter of urgency; research of the kind published by McAlearney and colleagues is capable of illuminating professional attitudes in a way that can form the basis for training and educational interventions. 15 The impact of the hardware in intimate healthcare settings and patients' views about computer use, and also about data storage and security, are becoming increasingly important, as is the need to provide evidence, from trials whenever possible, on the benefits in terms of health outcomes of engagement with current and future health-related technologies. All information contained in this survey will be treated in the strictest of confidence.…”