Docking glycosaminoglycans to proteins: analysis of solvent inclusion

Abstract

Glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) are anionic polysaccharides, which participate in key processes in the extracellular matrix by interactions with protein targets. Due to their charged nature, accurate consideration of electrostatic and water-mediated interactions is indispensable for understanding GAGs binding properties. However, solvent is often overlooked in molecular recognition studies. Here we analyze the abundance of solvent in GAG-protein interfaces and investigate the challenges of adding explicit solvent in GAG-protein docking experiments. We observe PDB GAG-protein interfaces being significantly more hydrated than protein–protein interfaces. Furthermore, by applying molecular dynamics approaches we estimate that about half of GAG-protein interactions are water-mediated. With a dataset of eleven GAG-protein complexes we analyze how solvent inclusion affects Autodock 3, eHiTs, MOE and FlexX docking. We develop an approach to de novo place explicit solvent into the binding site prior to docking, which uses the GRID program to predict positions of waters and to locate possible areas of solvent displacement upon ligand binding. To investigate how solvent placement affects docking performance, we compare these results with those obtained by taking into account information about the solvent position in the crystal structure. In general, we observe that inclusion of solvent improves the results obtained with these methods. Our data show that Autodock 3 performs best, though it experiences difficulties to quantitatively reproduce experimental data on specificity of heparin/heparan sulfate disaccharides binding to IL-8. Our work highlights the current challenges of introducing solvent in protein-GAGs recognition studies, which is crucial for exploiting the full potential of these molecules for rational engineering.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s10822-011-9433-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Targeting cancer-specific glycans by cyclic peptide lectinomimics

“…The charge of the ring oxygen of L-fucose is −0.68. Thus L-fucose can interact electrostatically with the positively charged side chain of Lys 5 and in this way contributing to its strongest binding affinity (Samsonov et al 2011) The docking of L-fucose to 2 and 3 showed similar docking poses, however slightly more different but in a similar region to the pose of L-fucose to 1 (Online Resource Fig. 14 ) .…”

Pharmacology of Heparin and Related Drugs

“…Where the main interest lies in identifying a heparin binding site, the calculations need not provide a full simulation of the protein-ligand complex in solution and cannot be relied on for the exact orientation of the ligand at the binding site (Forster and Mulloy, 2006). However, where detailed analysis of the interaction is required, greater care must be taken to accommodate complexities such as the conformational plasticity of the iduronate residue and the role of solvent in the interaction (Samsonov et al, 2011). A strategy for high-throughput screening of heparin/HS sequences has also been developed using docking calculations (Raghuraman et al, 2006).…”

Recent advances in employing molecular modelling to determine the specificity of glycan-binding proteins

“…Nevertheless, the relative lack of experimental structural data for these systems, combined with a growing awareness of their biological significance, has led to a number of innovative approaches to GAG docking. Recent examples include advances in the prediction of GAG binding sites [38,39], improvement in pose prediction via inclusion of specific bound waters [40], co-complex generation via threading and superimposition [41], mimetic discovery [42], as well as combining spectroscopic data with GAG modelling [43,44]. Very recently, an online utility for the automatic generation of 3D structures for GAGs has appeared (www.glycam.org/gag, [25]) that should find application in GAG modelling.…”