Do Urban Food Deserts Exist in the Global South? An Analysis of Nairobi and Mexico City

Abstract

Recent conceptualizations of ‘food deserts’ have expanded from a sole focus on access to supermarkets, to food retail outlets, to all household food sources. Each iteration of the urban food desert concept has associated this kind of food sourcing behavior to poverty, food insecurity, and dietary diversity characteristics. While the term continues to evolve, there has been little empirical evidence to test whether these assumed associations hold in cities of the Global South. This paper empirically tests the premises of three iterations of the urban food desert concept using household survey data collected in Nairobi, Kenya, and Mexico City, Mexico. While these associations are statistically significant and show the expected correlation direction between household food sourcing behavior and food security, the strength of these relationships tends to be weak. These findings indicate that the urban food desert concept developed in North American and UK cities may have limited relevance to measuring urban food insecurity in the Global South.

Dietary health perceptions and sources of nutritional knowledge in an urban food environment: a qualitative study from Indonesia

“…This observation contrasts with perceptions of low healthy foods availability often reported in studies focused on 'food deserts'underprivileged urban areas with little or no access to healthy food options (62) in high-income countries (67,75) . Findings feed into a growing body of evidence showing that the concept of food desertwhich originated in the context of anglophone high-income countriesmay not apply directly or universally to cities of LMIC (15,18,63,64) .…”

“…contextual and culturally varying (15)(16)(17)(18)(19) . They include differing attitudes towards food and eating in general (20,21) and towards specific products such as UPF and fast foods (21) .…”

Urban poverty and nutrition challenges associated with accessibility to a healthy diet: a global systematic literature review

“…fresh produce) and oftentimes products of lower quality [ 71 ]. Such fragmented market can lead to the establishment of informal arrangements, especially in low- and middle-income countries, such as street traders and house shops that are more likely to be unstable and deregulated [ 43 , 85 ]. Corner shops are another common source to meet food demand, but this has been associated with increased consumption of ultra-processed foods and inversely associated with home meal preparation, positive beliefs and self-efficacy toward healthy food [ 55 ].…”

Medición de inseguridad alimentaria-nutricional, hambre y estrategias de afrontamiento de niños y adolescentes en Medellín-Colombia

“…Para explicar la importancia del acceso físico a los alimentos que facilitan dietas saludables se han acuñado también los conceptos de oasis alimentario, que se asocia a la abundancia de alimentos adecuados, y el de pantanos alimentarios, referido a la abundancia de comida inadecuada para una alimentación saludable (Wagner et al, 2019). Los pantanos alimentarios son entornos de elección que además estimulan fuertemente el consumo de productos ultraprocesados y donde se incentivan acciones para la gratificación inmediata que, muy probablemente, conllevan el desarrollo de obesidad (Yang et al, 2012;Bridle-Fitzpatrick, 2015;Wagner et al, 2019;Ghosh-Distidar et al, 2014).…”