Do the needle type and the operator experience influence liver biopsy specimen quality?

This literature review was conducted to evaluate liver biopsy adequacy, including total core length (TCL), number of portal tracts (PT), fragmentation, and complication rates, as a function of needle type and gauge. A systematic electronic search was performed in the Web of Science and Google Scholar databases, according to the PRISMA statement. Eligible data, describing in vivo percutaneous ultrasound-guided human liver biopsy quality outcomes, were compared to adequacy criteria of the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases (AASLD, TCL ≥ 20 mm, PT ≥ 11). An adequate mean number of PTs was found in 83% of biopsy needles assessed between 2012 and 2019, compared to 0% between 1998 and 2004. For TCL, this was 44% and 33%, respectively. Increasing the needle diameter enhanced TCL (result in 50% of included studies) and PT count (100%), and reduced fragmentation rates (75%), whereas no effect on pain or complications was found (83%). In total, five needle types achieved adequate PT counts, using 16 G (3×), 17 G (1×), or 18 G (1×) needles. Adequacy was reached using either a core needle biopsy (CNB, 3×) approach with one pass, or a fine needle aspiration (FNA, 2×) approach with two passes. The recommendations for biopsy adequacy can be met using 16/17 G FNA or 16/18 G CNB needles. Currently, many publications still present substandard liver biopsy quality outcomes. Although minimizing biopsy invasiveness is desirable, a decreased diameter or number of passes is ill-judged when reliability of biopsy outcomes is at stake.

show abstract

“…2). Finally, type and experience of operators [19,22,27], as well as included hepatic diseases and severity [10,19], can affect biopsy adequacy.…”

Section: Discussionmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…Effect of Needle Type. Sporea et al [27] performed a multicenter study to compare the number of PTs of TruCut and Menghini needles. Used needle diameters were not mentioned.…”

Section: Number Of Portal Tractsmentioning

confidence: 99%