Do Pegmatites Crystallise Fast? A Perspective from Petrologically-Constrained Isotopic Dating

Abstract

Most recent studies consider the formation of individual pegmatite bodies to be a fast process with estimated crystal growth rates reaching a walloping 10 m/day. This opinion is presumably underpinned by the traditional way of thinking of them as the end products of magmatic fractionation. Indeed, modelling has shown that if a pegmatite-forming substance with a temperature near granitic solidus intrudes into a much colder host rock, as recorded in some outcrops, it must cool rapidly. From here, a conclusion is made that the crystallisation must likewise be rapid. However, this view is challenged by several studies that published isotopic dates supported by petrological characterisation of the analysed materials, which suggested or can be used to suggest that some minerals in pegmatites grew over millions of years. Surprisingly, such in-depth work on the geochronology of individual pegmatite bodies is relatively uncommon, so it is early to make generalisations. Here, I highlight some of the existing evidence with the aim to stimulate further research into the timescales of pegmatite crystallisation, including the use of petrologically constrained isotopic dating.