Do Neighborhoods Matter? A Systematic Review of Modifiable Risk Factors for Obesity among Low Socio-Economic Status Black and Hispanic Children

Abstract

Background: Childhood obesity increases the risk of obesity and harmful comorbidities later in life. It is influenced by characteristics of a child's neighborhood, particularly among underserved groups. Our objective was to systematically review the evidence relating neighborhood environment and obesity risk among urban, low socioeconomic status (SES) Black and Hispanic children. Methods: We included studies published from 1993 through early 2017 from PubMed, SCOPUS, Web of Science, and Sociological Abstracts databases investigating relationships between empirically measured neighborhood characteristics and obesity risk factors in the populations of interest. Databases were last searched on May 8, 2018. Initial analysis took place during 2014 and was completed during 2017. We extracted data on study population, design, and associations between neighborhood characteristics and obesity risk factors. Results: We identified 2011 unique studies; 24 were included. Few studies demonstrated consistent patterns of association. Most neighborhood characteristics were not examined across multiple studies. BMI may be related to living in a lower-income neighborhood or convenience store access. Conclusions: This review found that the body of evidence relating neighborhood exposures and obesity risk factors among urban, low SES Black (also commonly referred to in the literature as ''non-Hispanic Black'' or African American) and Hispanic children is limited. Given the high risk of obesity and cardiovascular disease among these populations throughout the life course, research on neighborhood determinants of obesity should specifically include these populations, ensuring adequate power and methodological rigor to detect differences.

The impact of change in neighborhood poverty on BMI trajectory of 37,544 New York City youth: a longitudinal study

“…Poverty is a key neighborhood characteristic that has recently received increased attention in efforts to establish the relationship between neighborhood and obesity [24,[34][35][36]. Neighborhood poverty may impact obesity via two potential pathways [37].…”

When Pandemics Collide: The Impact of COVID-19 on Childhood Obesity

“…Children with no place to go or no one to play with are less likely to engage in running, jumping, and performing large motor skills (Fegert et al, 2020). A recent systematic review suggests that body mass index may be related to living in a lower-income community ( Johnson et al, 2019 ). Data from two international studies found that better macro-economic indicators were related to lower rates of childhood obesity ( Olaya et al, 2015 ), and distance to green space was the most significant factor contributing to obesity in urban children (Manandhar et al, 2019).…”

A national examination of neighborhood socio-economic disparities in built environment correlates of youth physical activity

“…These statistics are concerning given that low physical activity in youth is associated with childhood obesity and other health conditions (e.g. diabetes, cardiovascular disease) and contributes to unhealthy lifestyles in adulthood ( Johnson et al, 2019 , Masoumi, 2017 , Rhodes et al, 2018 , Hallal et al, 2006 ). Ecological models of physical activity posit that factors across multiple levels, such as individual, psychosocial, environmental, and policy levels influence physical activity behaviors ( Molina-García et al, 2017 , Perez et al, 2017 ).…”