Do frogs really eat cardamom? Understanding the myth of crop damage by amphibians in the Western Ghats, India

Abstract

In the Western Ghats of India, amphibians are culled at cardamom plantations since they are perceived to consume cardamom. To better understand the relationship between amphibians and cardamom, a study was undertaken at these plantations, which harbor numerous threatened and range-restricted amphibians. We undertook questionnaire surveys with 298 respondents at 148 plantations across southern India. Time-activity budget and diet analysis surveys were undertaken to determine whether amphibians really consumed cardamom. The conception that amphibians eat cardamom was found to be widespread especially among small-sized plantations, leading to negative perceptions and a lack of interest in amphibian conservation. The plantation community perceives a substantial economic loss due to amphibians, even though this is non-existent as revealed by our field surveys. These perceptions would lead to a continued intolerance of amphibian presence in plantations. A suitable outreach initiative re-affirming facts and spreading awareness on the positive role of amphibians would need to be conducted to negate this age-old myth.

Using participatory video to share people’s experiences of neotropical urban green and blue spaces with decision‐makers

“…It was apparent that folklore was responsible for much of the negative attitudes expressed towards biodiversity, specifically manatees, snakes, and fish. Negative misconceptions of wildlife can lead to persecution, as seen with the Anaimalai gliding frog (Rhacophorus pseudomalabaricus) in India (Kanagavel et al, 2017) and the aye-aye lemur (Daubentonia madagascariensis) in Madagascar (Simons & Meyers, 2001), which are considered Critically Endangered and Endangered by the IUCN respectively. Elsewhere in Guyana, local communities alongside an NGO successfully prevented the continued population decline of Arapaima sp., a large freshwater fish surrounded by regional taboo and folklore, by changing the social norms regarding overfishing (Fernandes, 2006).…”

Amphibian community structure in Isau-Isau Wildlife Reserve, South Sumatra, Indonesia

“…Amphibians are highly sensitive to environmental degradation, with approximately 41% of known species threatened with extinction globally (IUCN 2021). Amphibians are known to play a role in the food chain as consumers, predators, prey, and bioindicators of environmental conditions (Hocking and Babbit 2014;Kanagavel et al 2017;Carlsson and Tydén 2018;Priambodo et al 2019). Therefore, their presence in nature cannot be ignored, and the conservation of species and their habitats should be prioritized.…”

Amphibian fauna of Pakistan with notes on future prospects of research and conservation

“…Amphibians are bioindicators of an ecosystem's health and may also serve as a biological control of crop and forest pests (Attademo et al 2005;Kanagavel et al 2017). Additionally, various important compounds have also been extracted from their skin and eggs for medical applications (Erspamer 1971;Clarke 1997).…”