“…4 In Guthrie et al (2009), we extend this caveat to the reliability of 3 The empirical literature has identified several opportunities to enrich current shareholders at the expense of outsiders without taking shareholder benefits explicitly into consideration. Examples include IPOs (Teoh et al, 1998a), SEOs (Rangan, 1998 andTeoh et al, 1998b), stock-for-stock acquisitions (Erickson and Wang, 1999), debt-covenant restrictions (DeFond and Jiambalvo, 1994), and earnings thresholds (Burgstahler and Dichev, 1997;Daniel et al, 2008;and Degeorge et al, 1999). 4 Note that Zhong et al and our findings are not at odds with each other.…”