As forest ecosystem services continue to decline, participatory forest management (PFM), a collective approach to forest management, is gaining traction as a means to promote livelihoods and conservation. As such, a number of analytical tools have been deployed in order to explore ways of enhancing PFM. Sequential Power Analysis (SPA) is rapidly becoming a robust approach for evaluating many natural resource sustainability outcomes in both developed and developing countries around the world. However, information on applying SPA to enhance participatory forest management is scarce. This study aimed to apply SPA to two community forest associations (CFAs) in Kenya in order to contribute to an improved understanding of the strategies for enhancing community involvement in forestry. A case study approach and literature review using document content analysis were used to evaluate secondary data from internet sources and office records at Kenya Forest Service. Key documents reviewed include policy papers and other documents. Through document content analysis, for the first time, the evaluation focused on the implications of SPA application in selected PFM scenarios by categorizing findings into three main themes: power delivery, power adjustment and power background and the policy implications on forest management in Kenya. The study found that achieving responsible forest management in Kenya depends on a delicate balance of ecological, social, and economic factors. PFM is a promising approach; however, evaluating its implementation in the Embaringo and Gathiuru CFAs using SPA reveals complex power dynamics. In Embaringo, historical and sociocultural factors have affected local communities. In Gathiuru, similar power imbalances exist, but the CFA is engaged in income-generating projects with the Kenya Forest Service (KFS), showing progress. However, to fully realize PFM's potential, Kenya should enact a national benefit-sharing policy to ensure fair resource benefit distribution. This study calls upon policymakers and key PFM stakeholders to embrace SPA as a crucial analytical tool for evaluating PFM decisions.