During base excision repair, DNA polymerase  fills 1-6-nucleotide gaps processively, reflecting a contribution of both its 8-and 31-kDa domains to DNA binding. Here we report the fidelity of pol  during synthesis to fill gaps of 1, 5, 6, or >300 nucleotides. Error rates during distributive synthesis by recombinant rat and human polymerase (pol)  with a 390-base gap are similar to each other and to previous values with pol  purified from tissues. The base substitution fidelity of human pol  when processively filling a 5-nucleotide gap is similar to that with a 361-nucleotide gap, but "closely-spaced" substitutions are produced at a rate at least 60-fold higher than for distributive synthesis. Base substitution fidelity when filling a 1-nucleotide gap is higher than when filling a 5-nucleotide gap, suggesting a contribution of the 8-kDa domain to the dNTP binding pocket and/or a difference in base stacking or DNA structure imposed by pol . Nonetheless, 1-nucleotide gap filling is inaccurate, even generating complex substitution-addition errors. Finally, the single-base deletion error rate during processive synthesis to fill a 6-nucleotide gap is indistinguishable from that of distributive synthesis to fill a 390-nucleotide gap. Thus the mechanism of processivity by pol  does not allow the enzyme to suppress template misalignments.
DNA polymerase  (pol )1 is the smallest of the mammalian cellular DNA polymerases. Evidence suggests that it can participate in several DNA transactions in vivo, including DNA replication (1, 2), recombination (3, 4), and base excision DNA repair (reviewed in Ref. 5). Base excision repair is needed to replace damaged nucleotides that are depurinated, deaminated, oxidized, or methylated as a result of normal cellular metabolism or environmental insult (reviewed in Ref. 6). There are at least two forms of base excision repair (BER) in mammalian cells (5). The predominant form is "simple" BER (7), involving excision of a single damaged nucleotide and its replacement catalyzed primarily by pol  (8, 9). Alternatively, BER may occur by excision of 2 to 6 nucleotides involving proliferating cell nuclear antigen and flap endonuclease 1, and DNA synthesis may be catalyzed by pol  (10, 11) or by pol ␦ or pol ⑀ (12, 13). This pathway is referred to as "alternate" BER.Early studies of the fidelity of DNA synthesis by pol  employed a long single-stranded template within a 390-nucleotide gap (14). The average pol  error rate for the 12 possible base substitution errors was 7 ϫ 10 Ϫ4 (15), while the average error rate for single-base deletion errors was 3-9 ϫ 10 Ϫ4 (16). These rates are substantially higher than those measured for the other cellular DNA polymerases that perform the bulk of genomic DNA replication (17). These higher error rates seem consistent with the fact that pol  lacks an intrinsic 3Ј 3 5Ј proofreading exonuclease activity. The observations that pol  has low frameshift fidelity and synthesizes DNA in a distributive manner during primer extension to copy long singlestr...