“…Experimental measurements were carried out by Meiburg and Lasheras (1988), Kamemoto (1992, 1993), Williamson (1996aWilliamson ( , 1996b, Prasad and Williamson (1997), Leweke and Williamson (1998), Luo et al (2003), for example. Thanks to advances in computation technology, direct numerical simulations (DNSs), adopting the finite volume method or spectral element method, have become increasingly common tools in recent decades (Meiburg and Lasheras 1988, Karniadakis and Triantafyllou 1992, Wu and Ling 1993, Persillon and Braza 1998, Darekar and Sherwin 2001, Posdziech and Grundmann 2001, Jiang et al 2016, 2017, Agbaglah and Mavriplis 2017, Lin et al 2018, 2019a, Jiang and Cheng 2019, Lin and Tan 2019b, 2022. Some theoretical methods, including linear and nonlinear stability analysis, typically for Floquet stability analysis, are sometimes adopted under certain circumstances (Barkley and Henderson 1996, Henderson 1997, Ling and Chang 1999, Barkley et al 2000, Posdziech and Grundmann 2001, Thompson et al 2001, Sheard et al 2003, Rao et al 2013, Clainche et al 2018, Lin et al 2019c.…”