B lymphocytes play a critical role in adaptive immunity. Upon antigen binding, B cell receptors (BCR) cluster on the plasma membrane and are internalized by endocytosis. B cells capture diverse antigens in various contexts and concentrations. However, it is unclear whether the mechanism of BCR endocytosis changes in response to these factors. Here, we studied the concentration dependence of anti-human IgM Fab'2-induced BCR clustering and internalization in the human IgM+ DG-75 B cell line using advanced imaging methods, including correlative super resolution fluorescence and electron microscopy. By directly visualizing nanoscale structures associated with BCR clusters, we provide evidence that BCR cluster size increases with Fab'2 concentration and the mechanism of internalization switches in response to BCR cluster size. At low concentrations of Fab'2, B cells internalize BCR clusters by classical clathrin-mediated endocytosis. However, at high Fab'2 concentrations, B cells retrieve clathrin-bound BCR clusters using large invaginations of the plasma membrane.