Divergent perceptions of the ‘neo-Australian’ forests of lowland eastern Madagascar: Invasions, transitions, and livelihoods

Abstract

Grevillea banksii (Proteaceae), a non-native shrubby tree, has in the past five decades expanded to cover hundreds of thousands of hectares in lowland eastern Madagascar, accompanied by other Australian and pan-tropical species, including Melaleuca quinquenervia, Acacia mangium, and Eucalyptus spp. We investigate contrasting perceptions of this new landscape with view to facilitate future management. Field research was based on 290 surveys, key informant interviews, and ecological inventories at six sites from Farafangana in the south to Fenerive Est in the north. After documenting the ecology and usage of grevillea, we analyse differing ways in which it can be perceived. Perceptions promoted by scientists and administrators include the contrasting ideas of beneficial landscape greening, rampant biological invasion, novel ecosystems, and forest transition. Perceptions held by local actors are highly determined by practical livelihood concerns. These local views are largely positive due to the major role of grevillea firewood and charcoal sales in livelihoods; however, context plays a major role and a number of disadvantages are perceived as well, including difficulty of removal, competition with crop and pasture land, and the respiratory health impacts of involvement in charcoal production. We conclude that policymakers and managers - in this case and in similar cases around the world - need to be more reflexive on the ways in which environmental problems are framed and to put those frames more in conversation with local people's experiences in order to productively resolve invasive species management dilemmas.

Plant Power: Opportunities and challenges for meeting sustainable energy needs from the plant and fungal kingdoms

“…Afforestation in countries such as Madagascar and Ethiopia with Grevillea species (Proteaceae, native to Australia) for primary fuel has resulted in unexpected land transformation due to the preferences of local people for native rather than exotic species (Kull, Harimanana, Radaniela Andrianoro, & Rajoelison, 2019). Similarly, cultivation of Jatropha curcas L. (Euphorbiaceae), a species native to Central and South America, for seed oil has had limited success in Africa and Asia (Antwi‐Bediako, Otsuki, Zoomers, & Amsalu, 2019; Castro Gonzáles, 2016).…”

Ten golden rules for reforestation to optimize carbon sequestration, biodiversity recovery and livelihood benefits

“…They may have set unrealistically high targets (Fagan et al, 2020) and may have unforeseen negative consequences. Potential problems include displacement of native biodiversity, particularly due to the destruction of non‐forest ecosystems (Seddon et al, 2019); increases in invasive species (Kull et al, 2019); a reduction in pollinator services (Ricketts et al, 2004); a reduction in croplands and thus food production; disruption of water cycles; a decrease in carbon stored in aboveground biomass (Heilmayr et al, 2020); a reduction in soil organic carbon ( SOC ; Hong et al, 2020; Veldman et al, 2019) and a lowering of albedo in boreal zones, causing temperature rises (Betts, 2000). These negative outcomes are mostly associated with the extensive use of exotic monoculture plantations, rather than restoration approaches that encourage a diverse, carbon‐rich mix of native tree species (Brancalion et al, 2018; Heilmayr et al, 2020; Lewis et al, 2019).…”

What Are the Grand Challenges for Plant Conservation in the 21st Century?

“…In Madagascar, for example, many afforestation projects use Eucalyptus spp. to provide wood for construction and fuel; these alien species, which evolved in very different systems, alter soil properties and water quality and alter fire regimes (Rakotondrasoa et al, 2012, Kull et al, 2019. Improving carbon storage while maintaining ecosystem integrity requires accurate understanding of carbon storage potential of native ecosystems and a thorough understanding of landscape history (Veldman et al, 2019).…”