Distributive politics as behavioral localism: Evidence from a vignette experiment in Hungary

Abstract

Recent literature on friends-and-neighbors voting focused on explaining citizens’ motives behind supporting local candidates; the cue-based account suggests that local ties signal accountability, constituency service orientation, and policy representation. Localism was also posited to serve as a cue for distributive politics, but assumptions of voters making inferences about receiving tangible benefits once a politician from their own stock is elected were not corroborated empirically. Drawing on a survey experiment ( N = 2000) fielded in Hungary, the paper provides a test of pork barrel politics and clientelism serving as manifestations of behavioral localism; that is, if voters formulate expectations of politicians engaging in aforementioned practices based on their local roots. Respondents in treatment and control group were shown the same candidate profile, fictive politicians differing only in their local roots. Results demonstrate that respondents who were told that the candidate was born and living in their hometown were more likely to believe that the politician will “bring home the bacon” as opposed to those confronted with a randomly selected Hungarian settlement as the candidate’s birthplace and residence. Findings refine our understanding of friends-and-neighbors voting, as well as voters’ expectations about likely non-programmatic behavior of elected candidates.

Probing the Effect of Candidate Localness in Low-Information Elections: Evidence from the German Local Level

“…Using data from Lithuania’s mixed-member majoritarian electoral system, Herron and Lynch (2019) find a localness effect for place of residence and birthplace and that this effect even seems to extend beyond constituency races into the party-list ballot. Drawing on a survey experiment fielded in Hungary before the 2022 general election, Kovarek (2022) shows that respondents who were told that a candidate was born and lives in their hometown were more likely to believe that the politician is likely to obtain government funds for their municipality.…”

The democratic backsliding paradigm in enlarged European Union countries: In-depth analysis of V-Dem indicators

“…In Poland, violations of the former can be seen immediately after the PiS government in 2015, but it was not until 2020 that electoral transparency deteriorated. Similarly, in Hungary, the Fidesz government of 2010 has been characterized by tight media regulation; clientelism and manipulations of its elections arose around 2014 (Agh, 2016;Kovarek, 2022). Turkey also experienced a slight decline in both indicators in 2008 when it reformed several acts influencing writers and publishers, followed by a continued decline in the freedom of expression score, and then a large decline in the clean elections indicator from 2014 to 2015.…”

Friends-and-Neighbours Effect at the 2020 Parliamentary Elections in Croatia

“…Postojanost F&N efekta potvrdili su znanstvenici iz Irske (Górecki i Marsh, 2012), Kanade (Blais i sur., 2003), Finske (Arter, 2011), Češke (Pileček, 2021) i mnogih drugih država, što znači da utjecaj blizine kandidata na izborno ponašanje birača nije ograničen na određeni izborni sustav, nego je karakteristika mnogih suvremenih demokracija (Górecki i Marsh, 2012). Recentna istraživanja F&N efekta provedena su i u hrvatskom susjedstvu (Červ, 2015;Tiran, 2022;Kovarek, 2022) sa sličnim teorijskim osnovama, ali različitom metodologijom istraživanja. U hrvatskoj znanstvenoj bibliografiji u novije vrijeme ističu se radovi koji promatraju geografsku utemeljenost hrvatske politike (Grdešić, 2013;Grdešić, 2021 i dr.).…”