“…More significantly, H. balthica first appears in VC9 a very short distance (10 cm) below the level of the 14 C date of 9264 AE 162 cal BP (Figure 2e, grey trend line). This particular interglacial benthic foraminiferal species is mainly a neritic to upper bathyal form (Rosenthal et al, 2011; see also Ross, 1984 andMinto'o, Bassetti, Toucanne, &Jouet, 2016 for discussion on its use as a palaeoclimatic indicator). This taxon is known to have first evolved in the early Pleistocene (e.g., Bayliss, 1969;Ross, 1984), or possibly even as early as the Pliocene (e.g., Hermelin, 1991); however, it has been noted as conspicuously absent before 10,000 BP in marine sediments recovered from the 1.…”