“…Data collected in D-Wave machines for the critical dynamics of the 1D TFIM is described by α = 0.20 in the NASA machine and by α = 0.34 in the Burnaby device [22], inconsistent with the unitary evolution of the quantum 1D TFIM. The values are also inconsistent with classical models including SVMC [22], simulated quantum annealing [56], and Glauber dynamics [57], and have been explained using a spin-boson model, coupling the quantum TFIM to an Ohmic harmonic bath. In this case, the theoretical value α KZM = 0.28 while a broader range is found numerically at zero temperature varying the spectral function [22].…”