Dispute inflation

Abstract

Much work has examined the phenomenon of dispute escalation, whereby the concrete measures state actors take edge them closer to war. Less attention has been devoted to the ways in which state actors’ perceptions of what is at stake in a dispute can also change, with important consequences for the likelihood of conflict. This paper examines the phenomenon of dispute inflation – wherein a contest over an object or issue assumes ever greater stakes and significance for its protagonists – and identifies three different mechanisms that can generate increasing non-material stakes. The upshot is that theoretically even a minor dispute can grow into a major conflict due to swelling stakes, especially when dispute inflation spirals. To illustrate these dynamics at work, this paper looks to recent developments in the dispute between the People’s Republic of China and Japan over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands.

Anger and Political Conflict Dynamics

“…This is because anger promotes deontological thinking, where actions adhere to moral rules rather than consequences (García-Ponce, Young, and Zeitzoff 2023). Angry individuals may prioritize "nonmaterial stakes" and be willing to forgo material gains to ensure wrongdoers face repercussions (Hall 2021). This behavior is evident in ultimatum bargaining games where unfair yet materially beneficial offers are often rejected, a tendency that is reduced when anger is mitigated (Pillutla and Keith Murnighan 1996;Srivastava, Espinoza, and Fedorikhin 2009).…”

Fear the fear: the historical analogies of COVID-19 in US–China relations

“…A closer examination of how fear was framed in China and the USA toward the other can enhance a better understanding of realism and constructivism. For example, the uncertainty of the other’s intentions would exacerbate the security dilemma, intensifying the military arms race (Lebow 2006 ; Hall 2021 ). Moreover, the changing power distribution and status ranking easily lead to fear for other countries, as the perceived weakness provides incentives for conquering and domination from the neighboring countries.…”