Search citation statements
Paper Sections
Citation Types
Year Published
Publication Types
Relationship
Authors
Journals
We express our appreciation to Dr. Yokobori for his interest in our paper [l] and for bringing to our attention their earlier paper [2] on dislocation dynamics theory for fatigue crack growth. Also, concerning Yokobori's comments on the priority of their dislocation model for the prediction of threshold stress intensity, we fail to see any discussion in [2] pertaining to the threshold stress intensity.Nevertheless, presuming that it is implicit in their equations, we shall now address the more fundamental question concerning the necessity for the two requirements.If their analysis [2] is correct, both force and energy considerations should give the same equilibrium configuration except in cases where there are non-conservative forces present, such as friction.In such cases equilibrium becomes path history dependent, and energy then provides a more fundamental parameter for the determination of the equilibrium configurations [6,7,8]. These requirements are the stress and energy which are claimed to providerespectively -the necessary and sufficient conditions for the dislocation generation.
From the historical perspective, we note that the nucleation of a dislocation from a crack tip was first treated by Armstrong [3].
We express our appreciation to Dr. Yokobori for his interest in our paper [l] and for bringing to our attention their earlier paper [2] on dislocation dynamics theory for fatigue crack growth. Also, concerning Yokobori's comments on the priority of their dislocation model for the prediction of threshold stress intensity, we fail to see any discussion in [2] pertaining to the threshold stress intensity.Nevertheless, presuming that it is implicit in their equations, we shall now address the more fundamental question concerning the necessity for the two requirements.If their analysis [2] is correct, both force and energy considerations should give the same equilibrium configuration except in cases where there are non-conservative forces present, such as friction.In such cases equilibrium becomes path history dependent, and energy then provides a more fundamental parameter for the determination of the equilibrium configurations [6,7,8]. These requirements are the stress and energy which are claimed to providerespectively -the necessary and sufficient conditions for the dislocation generation.
From the historical perspective, we note that the nucleation of a dislocation from a crack tip was first treated by Armstrong [3].