Discursive destabilisation of socio-technical regimes: Negative storylines and the discursive vulnerability of historical American railroads

Abstract

Incumbent socio-technical regimes based on fossil fuels probably cannot be destabilised to the extent necessary to achieve major reductions in carbon emissions without significant policy action. Policy actors, however, remain loyal to fossil fuels. Effective transitions to sustainability will therefore require the identification of political vulnerabilities in fossil fuel regimes. This article identifies one such vulnerability in the form of negative storylines. It describes the development of these storylines using the multi-level perspective on socio-technical transitions, as well as four dimensions of frame resonance developed in social movement theory. It then illustrates this phenomenon using an historical case study describing the development of negative storylines portraying the American railways as abusive monopolists during the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. These storylines played an important role in destabilising the railways, particularly when they also faced pressures from road transport, as policymakers were unwilling to relax regulations on a regime whose key actors they believed could not be trusted. This article argues that this pattern is unlikely to be unique to this case, but is rather a common development in incumbent socio-technical regimes. This article concludes by considering some implications of these findings for the destabilisation of existing fossil fuel regimes.

Rage against the regime: Niche-regime interactions in the societal embedding of plant-based milk

“…Negative debates about environmental, health or other aspects of food products are therefore likely to strike a chord with the wider public. These normative contestations, which we figuratively refer to as 'rage against the regime' 3 , may erode and destabilise the cultural legitimacy of existing regimes (Elzen et al, 2011;Roberts, 2017). Additionally, cultural debates may stimulate niche development (Geels and Verhees, 2011), because positive meanings may attract attention and influence consumer purchasing.…”

The politics of accelerating low-carbon transitions: Towards a new research agenda

“…For example, the level of resistance to nuclear energy in Germany compared with France, or to fracking in the United Kingdom compared with the United States show that policy success in supporting certain technologies can depend a great deal on their cultural legitimacy, which depends on local cultural and discursive factors. Roberts [76] shows that broad cultural discourses, (an anti-trust mentality in his case study on the American railways), can destabilise powerful incumbent socio-technical regimes. Kuzemko et al [18] show the importance of democratic structures, norms and values in governing energy system change.…”

Transformation pathways of phasing out coal-fired power plants in Germany

“…A phase-out of coal-fired power plants would imply significant losses in the budget of municipalities. There are also highly localized historical reasons for sticking to an old technology, in particular coal mining which is often seen in melancholic terms, and acts as a further lock-in effect [71].…”