By introducing a GAC anticodon, 21 different Escherichia coli tRNAs were misacylated with either phenylalanine or valine and assayed for their affinity to Thermus thermophilus elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu)⅐GTP by using a ribonuclease protection assay. The presence of a common esterified amino acid permits the thermodynamic contribution of each tRNA body to the overall affinity to be evaluated. The E. coli elongator tRNAs exhibit a wide range of binding affinities that varied from ؊11.7 kcal͞mol for Val-tRNA Glu to ؊8.1 kcal͞mol for Val-tRNA Tyr , clearly establishing EF-Tu⅐GTP as a sequence-specific RNA-binding protein. Because the ionic strength dependence of koff varied among tRNAs, some of the affinity differences are the results of a different number of phosphate contacts formed between tRNA and protein. Because EF-Tu is known to contact only the phosphodiester backbone of tRNA, the observed specificity must be a consequence of an indirect readout mechanism. E longation factor Tu (EF-Tu) binds GTP and aminoacyl tRNA (aa-tRNA) to form a ternary complex that subsequently binds ribosome and participates in codon-directed binding of the aa-tRNA to the ribosomal A site. Although EFTu⅐GTP binds poorly to tRNAs lacking the esterified amino acid (1), the protein is generally considered to lack specificity because it binds all elongator aa-tRNAs with a similar affinity (2-4). However, recent experiments have shown that EF-Tu⅐GTP exhibits substantial specificity for both the esterified amino acid and the tRNA body of aa-tRNAs (5). This specificity was previously unappreciated because the contributions of the amino acid and the tRNA body to the overall affinity are arranged in a compensatory manner such that the cognate aa-tRNAs all bind with similar affinities. However, misacylated tRNAs were found to bind EF-Tu⅐GTP with a wide range of affinities that were either tighter or weaker than the cognate aa-tRNAs (5). The four different tRNA bodies that were tested displayed about a 100-fold range of K D values with Thermus thermophilus EFTu⅐GTP when each was esterified with the same amino acid. The same range of K D values was observed when the four tRNAs were esterified with a different common amino acid, clearly establishing that EF-Tu shows specificity toward the tRNA body. However, the four tRNAs used in these experiments (Escherichia coli tRNA Ala , tRNA Gln , tRNA Val , and yeast tRNA Phe ) have very similar overall architectures, raising the possibility that EFTu⅐GTP could exhibit a much larger range of affinities with tRNAs of different architectures.Experiments presented here take advantage of the important role of the anticodon as a identity element for valyl-tRNA synthetase (ValRS) and phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (PheRS) (6-10) to prepare 21 different E. coli tRNAs that were misacylated with either valine or phenylalanine. By comparing the affinities of the different tRNAs esterified with a common amino acid, the specificity of EF-Tu⅐GTP for the different tRNA bodies was established.
Materials and MethodsE. coli...