“…Such a modulation has been used for advanced experimental implementations [4][5][6] , but is not a common industrial practice; a more practical approach is to send coherent states chosen from a finite constellation in phase space. Although such discrete modulations were considered early in CV-QKD [12][13][14] , sound security proofs have been developed only recently, for protocols with either very large constellation sizes 15 or very small ones [16][17][18][19] , with some experimental implementations in the latter case 20,21 . But the most interesting format of medium-size quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM) used in classical optical communications remained out of reach for these methods, which rely on solving huge convex optimization problems.…”