Discovering the Unfindable: The Tension Between Findability and Discoverability in a Bookshop Designed for Serendipity

Abstract

Serendipity is a key aspect of user experience, particularly in the context of information acquisition-where it is known as information encountering. Unexpectedly encountering interesting or useful information can spark new insights while surprising and delighting. However, digital environments have been designed primarily for goal-directed seeking over loosely-directed exploration, searching over discovering. In this paper we examine a novel physical environment-a bookshop designed primarily for serendipity-for cues as to how information encountering might be helped or hindered by digital design. Naturalistic observations and interviews revealed it was almost impossible for participants to find specific books or topics other than by accident. But all unexpectedly encountered interesting books, highlighting a tension between findability and discoverability. While some of the bookshop's design features enabled information encountering, others inhibited it. However, encountering was resilient, as it occurred despite participants finding it hard to understand the purpose of even those features that did enable it. Findings suggest the need to consider how transparent or opaque the purpose of design features should be and to balance structure and lack of it when designing digital environments for findability and discoverability.

Information behavior patterns: A new theoretical perspective from an empirical study of naturalistic information acquisition

“…To identify information behavior patterns in an arts and crafts context, we conducted a naturalistic qualitative observation study with recruited participants in digital and physical information environments: Pinterest (pinterest.com) and a brick-and-mortar crafts store located in a U.S. Midwest college town. The selected store is characterized by its donated items and unique approach to shelving products, akin to the bookshop designed for serendipity in prior research (Makri et al, 2019). Rather than organizing items by their object types, the staff focuses on sizes and quantities of items, tending to re-shelve everything in the store frequently.…”

Designing for serendipity: a means or an end?

“…However, "unexpected events always are unplanned, but unplanned events are not always unexpected given the situation" (Bj€ orneborn, 2017, p. 1067). Indeed, a bookshop, designed to foster serendipity and also communicates this to its customers as such, has still been found to trigger experiences of serendipity (Makri et al, 2019). As a result, experiences of serendipity may arise even when one expects it.…”

Hey Alexa, What Should I Read? Comparing the Use of Social and Algorithmic Recommendations for Different Reading Genres

“…This is an implicit but effective recommendation for the reader [ 36 ]. Recommendations from sources unknown to the reader, though, are often disregarded as irrelevant or not authoritative, such as the reader in [ 37 ] who commented “ oh, there’s a curator[of a section]. But I don’t know who she is, so don’t really care.…”