We have compared the ability of thrombincleaved C9 (C9") with that of native C9 to produce tubular or ring-like poly(C9) and to express the classical complement lesion on target membranes. Three procedures were used to produce poly(C9): (i) limited proteolysis with trypsin, (it) interaction with small unilamellar lipid vesicles, and (iii) incubation with a 2-to 4-fold molar excess of ZnC12. In contrast to C9, which could be converted to tubular poly(C9), C9n was converted to smaller peptides by the first procedure and was aggregated into string-like poly(C9) by the other two methods. C9-depleted human serum (R-9 serum) was reconstituted with either C9 or C9" and these sera were then used to lyse sensitized sheep erythrocytes. Numerous classical complement lesions could be detected on ghost membranes obtained from cells lysed by C9-reconstituted R-9 serum but only a few on ghost membranes produced by C9n-reconstituted R-9 serum. C9' was shown to be hemolytically as active as C9 even when tested under "single-hit" conditions and it was about twice as efficient when compared with C9 in releasing sucrose and inulin from resealed ghosts. These results are interpreted to indicate that formation of the classical complement lesion is only incidental to lysis and not an obligatory event and that enlargement of the "functional pore size" of the complement lesion is not linked to formation of a circular membrane attack complex.One hallmark of serum complement is its ability to lyse erythrocytes and bacteria and it is now axiomatic that lysis results from the formation of lesions on the target membrane. The structural entity associated with the complement lesion was first visualized in the electron microscope by Dourmashkin and co-workers (1-3) as a ring-like structure of v20 nm outer and -10 nm inner diameter. Those researchers also showed that formation of the morphological lesion requires participation of all five terminal complement proteins, including C9, although lysis of sheep erythrocytes proceeds in the absence of C9 (4). Based in part on the physical appearance of the lesion in the electron microscope and in part on the properties of low molecular weight ionophores, Mayer (5) introduced the "doughnut" theory, which describes the lesion as a stable hollow structure composed of proteins C5b, C6, C7, C8, and C9. This structure was considered to provide a water-filled transmembrane pore of -10 nm diameter that allows polar substances to equilibrate across the hydrophobic membrane barrier, and cell death results from ensuing colloid-osmotic effects.An alternative view for the mechanism of immune hemolysis was presented by Kinsky (6) and Lachmann and coworkers (7,8), who suggested that lysis is caused by a detergent-like action of the terminal complement proteins that assemble on the target to form a "leaky patch." This hypothesis is supported by studies by Esser and co-workers, (9-11), who investigated the effect of the terminal proteins on lipid organization in the target membrane and the mechanism of virolysi...