Direct Outcomes and Win-Win Relationships Between University Careers Advisors and Graduate Recruiters

Abstract

The purpose of our paper is to apply the state progress checklist from direct outcomes theory to a new domain of the university-to-work transition to mediate a dyadic win-win relationship between university careers advisors and graduate recruiters. The state progress checklist incorporates three endeavour elements - (i) potential, (ii) agendas, and (iii) effects; and nine themes - (i) resources, (ii) motivations, (iii) interactions, (iv) assumptions, (v) scenarios, (vi) plans, (vii) actions, (viii) outcomes, and (ix) reuses. The endeavour elements and themes are systematically applied to help envision, pursue, and achieve mutually beneficial relationships between both parties. The application of direct outcomes theory as a mediator of the relationship between university careers services and graduate recruiters offers synergy effects for both parties and helps overcome pre-existing barriers to collaboration and communication. Our paper applies the state progress checklist from direct outcomes theory to a new domain of the university-to-work transition to bridge research agendas across the education, vocational behaviour, and human resource management literature. We identify opportunities for university careers services and graduate recruiters to foster a win-win relationship by aligning their objectives and through the provision and receiving of support. These benefits subsequently transcend additional stakeholders, including university students, universities, and organisations. Moreover, Appendix 1 provides a summary sheet offering some potential questions for each of the nine themes across the three endeavour elements. These example questions are not meant to be an exhaustive list. Their purpose is to act as a starting point for discussion and action. The university careers advisors and graduate recruiters could initially work through this sheet separately before working through the sheet a second time collaboratively.

Effects of career development learning on students’ perceived employability: a longitudinal study

“…In addition to offering these activities, universities should ensure that such activities are accessible to all groups of students (Jackson & Bridgstock, 2021 ). From the student perspective, they should participate actively in CDL activities, including by researching the labour market, listening to employers regarding job requirements and opportunities and participating in work-integrated learning (Buckholtz & Donald, 2022 ; Pitan, 2016 ).…”

Can Embedding Authentic Assessment Into the Curriculum Enhance the Employability of Business School Students?

“…Educators can develop their networks with industry, improve engagement with their students, and feel a sense of enrichment from their work (Koh et al, 2012). Career advisors benefit since authentic assessment focuses on the development of student employability, offering ways to overcome challenges highlighted in the vocational behaviour literature regarding engaging students in career support initiatives (Buckholtz & Donald, 2022;Donald et al, 2018). These benefits transcend to the university level via increased league table rankings and TEF scores which can subsequently be used to attract prospective students and associated revenue streams.…”

Preparing for a Sustainable Career

“…This may involve participation in clubs, societies, charity work or paid work to develop resources and build personal networks. Additionally, students need to seek career guidance early during their degree studies, and university career services must partner with industry to share resources and foster win-win outcomes (Buckholtz & Donald, 2022). Finally, the ability to signal one's employability is crucial for success (Anderson & Tomlinson, 2021).…”