Digitalizing Health Services by Implementing a Personal Electronic Health Record in Germany: Qualitative Analysis of Fundamental Prerequisites From the Perspective of Selected Experts

Abstract

Background The implementation of a personal electronic health record (PHR) is a central objective of digitalization policies in the German health care system. Corresponding legislation was passed with the 2015 Act for Secure Digital Communication and Applications in the Health Sector (eHealth Act). However, compared with other European countries, Germany still lags behind concerning the implementation of a PHR. Objective In order to explore potential barriers and facilitators for the adoption of a PHR in routine health care in Germany, this paper aims to identify policies, structures, and practices of the German health care system that influence the uptake and use of a PHR. Methods A total of 33 semistructured interviews were conducted with a purposive sample of experts: 23 interviews with different health care professionals and 10 interviews with key actors of the German health care system who were telematics, eHealth, and information technology experts (eHealth experts). The interviews were transcribed verbatim and subjected to a content analysis. Results From the expert perspective, a PHR was basically considered desirable and unavoidable. At the same time, a number of challenges for implementation in Germany have been outlined. Three crucial themes emerged: (1) documentation standards: prevailing processes of the analog bureaucratic paper world, (2) interoperability: the plurality of actors and electronic systems, and (3) political structure: the lack of clear political regulations and political incentive structures. Conclusions With regard to the implementation of a PHR, an important precondition of a successful digitalization will be the precedent reform of the system to be digitized. Whether the recently passed Act for Faster Appointments and Better Care will be a step in the right direction remains to be seen.

Lung cancer patients’ comorbidities and attendance of German ambulatory physicians in a 5-year cross-sectional study

“…Although the use of electronic patients’ records could be a solution to overcome barriers in cross-sectoral healthcare, their implementation is still a major challenge 25 . One of the reasons for the difficulties in implementing telemedicine is the very restrictive data protection laws in Germany.…”

“…In addition to interoperability as a central prerequisite for digitization, government policy is seen as a relevant component. Therefore, it is the task of politics to improve the necessary framework conditions for the successful implementation of e-health in the healthcare system to support healthcare across service sectors 25 . Furthermore, the users’ attitude towards e-health must be considered.…”

A Platform for Health Record Management of the Conscripts in the Hellenic Navy

“…eMass reinforces the enhancement and establishment in the overall process of medical data collection and recording. Moreover, additional cases are identified for further examination and the conscripts are benefited from a thorough examination [2]. The exploitation of a recruiter's EHR through the deployment of the machine-learning based cardiovascular risk assessment tool is one of the notable eMass assets.…”

“…eMass project develops a platform that expedites the medical examination procedure of recruitment process in the Hellenic Navy. The platform integrates recruits' Electronic Health Record (EHR) by extracting appropriate health indicators, which are considered as a significant key factor for actions towards recruits' medical assessment [2]. Specifically, an EHR will be conducted for each recruit by the staff of the army classification unit, in which, recruit's demographics, personal and family medical history will be stored.…”

Caregivers' role in using a personal electronic health record: a qualitative study of cancer patients and caregivers in Germany

“…Despite the growing relevance of PHRs and caregivers' access to them, there is so far no consensus on the clear role for caregivers in the use of a PHR. Therefore, one objective of the underlying research project "Information Technology for patient-oriented health care in the Rhine-Neckar region (INFOPAT)" was not only to develop a patient-centered PHR by involving patients themselves but also to illuminate the caregivers' attitudes and opinions regarding this subject [8,[12][13][14][15][16][17].…”