Digital Image Analysis of Cigarette Filter Stains as an Indicator of Compensatory Smoking

Abstract

Objective: Cigarette filters trap a significant portion of carcinogen-containing smoke particulate and may provide an indication of cigarette constituent exposure. A technique for quantifying filter tar staining with digital imaging has shown predictive value between typical total puff volume and filter tar stain intensity. The current study uses smoking topography data acquired during an examination of compensatory smoking of Quest cigarettes and digital analyses of the tar stains of the spent Quest cigarette filters. Due to reduced nicotine levels, we hypothesized compensatory smoking to occur. The purposes of the current study were to describe the physical characteristics of the Quest cigarettes, to further validate the effect of puff volume on filter tar staining, and to examine the effect of compensatory smoking on changes in filter tar staining, hypothesizing that compensatory smoking would result in more intense tar staining. Methods: Physical characteristics of the Quest cigarettes were measured to characterize the product. Spent cigarette filters were digitally analyzed for color intensity features, matched to smoking topography measures, and examined in regression models. Difference scores for digital imaging and smoking topography were used in a regression model to identify the effect of compensatory smoking on tar stain. Conclusion:Results suggest that compensatory smoking may be detectable by darkening and reddening of the tar stain. This type of measure could be useful in quantifying the extent to which human smokers smoke differently than standard testing protocols and in assessing the prevalence of compensatory smoking in population samples. (Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 2006;15(12):2565 -9)

Nicotine Metabolite Ratio Predicts Smoking Topography and Carcinogen Biomarker Level

“…Nicotine, the primary addictive compound in tobacco, is metabolized to cotinine (COT), and then to 3'-hydroxycotinine (3HC), predominantly by the hepatic CYP2A6 enzyme (2, 3). Smokers can extract varying levels of nicotine by altering their smoking topography (e.g., puff volume, number of puffs) (4–6), which in turn can affect level of toxin exposure (6–8). …”

PREP advertisement features affect smokers’ beliefs regarding potential harm

“…Forty per cent of participants had at least a 20% increase in carbon monoxide boost when smoking the lowest nicotine level Quest compared to the highest nicotine level Quest. Further, a digital analysis technique7 of the tar stain intensity in the used Quest filters suggests a relative increase in carcinogen-containing tar when smoking the lower nicotine level Quest compared to the higher nicotine level 8…”

The Process of Cigarette Smoking

“…Techniques of smoking, including frequency, volume of puffi ng, and types of cigarette fi lters [140] , also affect which chemicals enter into the body. Manufacturerbased differences in types of cigarettes or tobacco smoked, cigarette additives, inhaled, or chewed have made the defi nition of a standard smoker diffi cult to achieve.…”