Different perceptions of narrative medicine between Western and Chinese medicine students

Abstract

BackgroundWestern medicine is an evidence-based science, whereas Chinese medicine is more of a healing art. To date, there has been no research that has examined whether students of Western and Chinese medicine differentially engage in, or benefit from, educational activities for narrative medicine. This study fills a gap in current literature with the aim of evaluating and comparing Western and Chinese Medicine students’ perceptions of narrative medicine as an approach to learning empathy and professionalism.MethodsAn initial 10-item questionnaire with a 5-point Likert scale was developed to assess fifth-year Western medical (MS) and traditional Chinese medical (TCMS) students’ perceptions of a 4-activity narrative medicine program during a 13-week internal medicine clerkship. Exploratory factor analysis was undertaken.ResultsThe response rate was 88.6% (412/465), including 270 (65.5%) MSs and 142 (34.5%) TCMSs, with a large reliability (Cronbach alpha = 0.934). Three factors were extracted from 9 items: personal attitude, self-development/reflection, and emotional benefit, more favorable in terms of enhancement of self-development/reflection. The perceptions of narrative medicine by scores between the two groups were significantly higher in TCMSs than MSs in all 9-item questionnaire and 3 extracted factors.ConclusionsGiven the different learning cultures of medical education in which these student groups engage, this suggests that undertaking a course in Chinese medicine might enhance one’s acceptance to, and benefit from, a medical humanities course. Alternatively, Chinese medicine programmes might attract more humanities-focused students.

How does narrative medicine impact medical trainees’ learning of professionalism? A qualitative study

“…Outcomes of narrative medicine for professionalism learning: empathy, communication, doctor-patient relationship, and understanding patients Empathy, one of the core components of professionalism, has been identified as an essential component of the doctor-patient relationship [8,42]. It is the ability to understand patients' situation, perspective, and feelings and to communicate that understanding to them [43].…”

Evidence‐based traditional Chinese medicine research: Two decades of development, its impact, and breakthrough

“…In 2020, an international reporting standard of the TCM guidelines, RIGHT‐TCM was proposed, 82,83 which will promote the TCM evidence translation combined with the estimation of the TCM evidence grading and recommendation system 84–87 . Furthermore, researchers introduced TCM concepts and theories into the development of core outcome sets 88,89 and the practice of narrative medicine 90 ‐ 92…”

Reading Between the Lines: A Five-Point Narrative Approach to Online Accounts of Illness

“…As yet, however, there is inconsistent representation of narrative elements in medical programs. Medical education, in the West at least (Huang et al 2017), is still steeped in logicoscientific thinking (Gupta et al 2011). Prominence is given to comprehending the bio-medical clues that will lead to evidence-based explanations or which will guide evidence-based investigations.…”