Dietary, physical activity, and weight management interventions among active-duty military personnel: a systematic review

Abstract

BackgroundResearch has been conducted to assess the effectiveness of weight management, dietary and physical activity interventions in military settings. However, a recent and comprehensive overview is lacking. The aim of this systematic review is to examine the evidence and describe key components of effective interventions in terms of improving body composition, dietary behaviors, and physical activity among active-duty military personnel.MethodsPubMed, PsycInfo, and CINAHL were searched on the 17th of November 2017 to identify interventions that promoted diet and/or physical activity among active-duty military personnel. Studies were included if they assessed outcomes related to anthropometric measurements, dietary behaviors, or fitness/physical activity levels. There were no restrictions regarding publication date, follow-up duration, and sex. After screening, a total of 136 studies were eligible. Of these studies, 38 included an educational and/or behavioral change component, and 98 had only physical or fitness training as part of basic military training. Only studies that included an educational and/or behavioral change component were assessed for quality using the Effective Public Health Practice Project tool and included in the qualitative synthesis of the results.ResultsBased on consistent evidence from studies that were rated as moderate or strong, there is good evidence that military weight management interventions are effective in improving body composition for durations of up to 12 months. Effective interventions are more likely to be high intensity (have a greater number of sessions), are more often delivered by specialists, and use theoretical base/behavioral change techniques and a standardized guideline. Dietary interventions can potentially reduce total fat and saturated fat intake. Dietary interventions that target the kitchen staff and/or increase the availability of healthy food are more likely to be effective in the short term. The results regarding military physical fitness interventions were inconclusive.ConclusionDespite limitations such as the diversity and heterogeneity of the included interventions, outcome measurements, and follow-up duration, this systematic review found good evidence that weight management interventions are effective, especially in terms of weight loss. More studies are needed to acquire solid evidence for effectiveness for durations longer than 12 months and to identify key components of the effective dietary and physical activity educational and/or behavioral change interventions, especially in countries outside Europe and the US.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s40779-018-0190-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Dynamics of Indicators of Cadets' Physical Development and Functional Status during Pentathlon

“…This, in turn, increases the requirements for professional training of service members. As it is known that no matter how modern and powerful a weapon is, it is still controlled by the military [4,5].…”

Characteristics of Morphofunctional State of Paratrooper Cadets in the Process of CrossFit Training

“…Professional military (combat) activity of AAF officers takes place in extreme conditions and this complicates the performance of assigned tasks. It is characterized by diversity, intensity, and specificity, significant physical activity, which generally places high demands on physical fitness of military personnel, in particular, it requires the universality, the readiness to act in any situation, environment, and time [4,5,6,7].…”

Life in the army reserves – the balance of work, training and physical activity: an ethnographic study

“…HMAF-UK encourages and in many cases mandates PA participation. Within the military PA is used implicitly and explicitly (Thomas et al 2004;Sharp et al 2017;Malkawi et al 2018). Whilst a body of evidence using training studies and interventions exists (see Malkawi et al 2018) research is yet to explore the acceptability and feasibility of PA from the perspective of the soldiers and officers.…”

“…Within the military PA is used implicitly and explicitly (Thomas et al 2004;Sharp et al 2017;Malkawi et al 2018). Whilst a body of evidence using training studies and interventions exists (see Malkawi et al 2018) research is yet to explore the acceptability and feasibility of PA from the perspective of the soldiers and officers. Most often, PA in infantry (combat) units is mandated and occupational and experienced implicitly often within a simulated warzone environment (e.g., through training exercises and packages) (Thomas et al 2004).…”

“…Whilst PA can contribute to improved employee-and organisational-level health outcomes (Batt 2009;Conn et al 2009), it is interesting to note that data from HMAF-UK suggests that 34% are not satisfied with the provision of leisure-time PA (MOD 2018). Given the majority of the evidence using leisure-time PA and training within military settings focuses on healthmarkers, fitness and operational effectiveness (Anderson et al 2017;Malkawi et al 2018;Martins and Lopes 2013;de la Motte et al 2019), and the association between these activities and illbeing, it appears prudent to understand the behaviours, wellbeing, emotions and motivation of those experiencing these forms of training.…”